mangotflu

2y

Where's this data even from? Wait For U doing 31m/week in week 6 when it was "only" doing 7m a week on spotify doesn't add up considering Carnival is doing 20m on Spotify but according to you only 30m total

mangotflu

2y

Life is Good youtube thing is one of the most suspicious things to happen to music over the last few years, even thegreatdivine can't explain that one

mangotflu

2y

if you value longevity then Carnival is the biggest rap hit in years at this rate surely, maybe since Sicko Mode?

i think the song's terrible so I don't get it

John Mauve

2y

Currently watching: John Cena vs The Rock Wrestlemania 29 FULL MATCH

Up next:

Wiggler

2y

Everyone forgot about The Box

Raplic Priest

2y

47k in week 5? Remember all the people saying 40k first week

mangotflu

2y

if you value longevity then Carnival is the biggest rap hit in years at this rate surely, maybe since Sicko Mode?

i think the song's terrible so I don't get it

Midzy

2y

I can name 20

mangotflu

2y

Life is Good youtube thing is one of the most suspicious things to happen to music over the last few years, even thegreatdivine can't explain that one

Midzy

2y

I can name 20

roselei

2y

There’s realistically like 5-6 that can be argued. Carnival being the first hip-hop song this decade to be #1 on every major streaming service simultaneously puts it in a tier of its’ own

My Turn

2y

"Carnival being the first hip-hop song this decade to be #1 on every major streaming service simultaneously puts it in a tier of its’ own"

nope. this is like a boogie getting a #1 album selling 45k

roselei

2y

That’s not how that works at all

My Turn

2y

how is it any different?

roselei

2y

There’s realistically like 5-6 that can be argued. Carnival being the first hip-hop song this decade to be #1 on every major streaming service simultaneously puts it in a tier of its’ own

roselei

2y

It’s like saying For All the Dogs won’t go down as one of the biggest albums of the decade because it “only” sold 400K first week. You have to judge these things on a relative basis.

mov

2y

Can someone ban Dedications alt

My Turn

2y

That is not the same at all....

you said "Carnival being the first hip-hop song this decade to be #1 on every major streaming service simultaneously puts it in a tier of its’ own"

I disagree because going #1 when charts are weak does not prove anything ie a boogie going #1 with 45k sales

roselei

2y

So, by your metric, going #1 with an album when the charts are weak doesn’t mean anything either right?

So every #1 album that’s released in the past year means nothing right?

As well as every #1 song that’s released within the past year right?