Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Well that’s what happens when your music keeps people satisfied for years. Weeknd has a new song crossing a billion streams every other day

    I swear you might d***ride weeknd more than thegreatdivine d***rides drake never seen you criticise anything about the weeknd ever

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies
    TheFader

    It's not about numbers. Michael Jackson's highest grossing tour only grossed $165 million.

    There are way more factors than just numbers

    Come on man Taylor has literally almost the entire female population of the world obsessed with her lol. Beyonce never even had half her fanbase

    People barely care about Beyonce outside of the US. I actually think Taylor is 5x bigger than Beyonce outside of the US

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Come on man Taylor has literally almost the entire female population of the world obsessed with her lol. Beyonce never even had half her fanbase

    People barely care about Beyonce outside of the US. I actually think Taylor is 5x bigger than Beyonce outside of the US

    Bey filled out stadiums in Europe last year

  • TheFader

    Maybe being a better performer, vocalist, and just overall artist in general?

    The spreadsheets really gave half of these posters brain rot when taking about Taylor mid lol

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    edited
    ·
    3 replies
    Botney

    Bey filled out stadiums in Europe last year

    Yeah I meant relative to her stature in the US

    There's a huge difference between doing like 12 stadium dates outside of the US vs what Taylor's doing with the Eras Tour

    it's nuts to compare them at this point

    the closest artist to Taylor is Adele and then Harry Styles tbh

  • SWAN đź’ś
    Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    2 replies
    mangotflu

    Yeah I meant relative to her stature in the US

    There's a huge difference between doing like 12 stadium dates outside of the US vs what Taylor's doing with the Eras Tour

    it's nuts to compare them at this point

    the closest artist to Taylor is Adele and then Harry Styles tbh

    No.

    Beyonce is bigger than Harry when it comes to touring

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    SWAN

    No.

    Beyonce is bigger than Harry when it comes to touring

    The gap w/ touring isn't as big as you think between them

    But the gap w/ music popularity is actually huge outside of the US, which is why I think Harry's bigger as of right now

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    Harry even sells way more actual physical albums than Beyonce everywhere (incl US) lol, which is actually insane considering he's a "new gen" artist

    Harry's House almost sold more pure in the US (330k) than Cowboy Carter (168k) and renaissance (190k) combined

  • SWAN đź’ś
    Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    The gap w/ touring isn't as big as you think between them

    But the gap w/ music popularity is actually huge outside of the US, which is why I think Harry's bigger as of right now

    I thought you were strictly talking about touring. In that regard, Beyoncé is much more successful. While they grossed roughly the same amount, Harry had to do three times as many shows

    When it comes to music sales, Harry is, of course, much bigger than Beyoncé. She’s pretty much a legacy act at this point

  • Dec 4, 2024
    SWAN

    I thought you were strictly talking about touring. In that regard, Beyoncé is much more successful. While they grossed roughly the same amount, Harry had to do three times as many shows

    When it comes to music sales, Harry is, of course, much bigger than Beyoncé. She’s pretty much a legacy act at this point

    Harry's tour grew a lot though, for some reason it was a 2+ year long tour where a lot of the early dates were arenas, then it became much stadiums

    I really do think that Harry can do way more stadiums in Europe/Asia than Beyonce. US is where Beyonce smokes Harry $ wise though, those US dates do like 2x+ more revenue than EU/Asia dates

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    2 replies
    SWAN

    No.

    Beyonce is bigger than Harry when it comes to touring

    No, she isn't and you'll see the next time Harry tours.

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Harry even sells way more actual physical albums than Beyonce everywhere (incl US) lol, which is actually insane considering he's a "new gen" artist

    Harry's House almost sold more pure in the US (330k) than Cowboy Carter (168k) and renaissance (190k) combined

    Yes, and Beyoncé was outselling Madonna in 2003

    Doesn't mean she's bigger than Madonna overall

    Newer big artists will always do better than older artists

    You are ed

  • Dec 4, 2024
    thegreatdivine

    No, she isn't and you'll see the next time Harry tours.

    I'm ngl I thought you'd rip into me for what i'm saying lol. i didn't expect you to agree.

  • Dec 4, 2024
    jack johnson

    Yes, and Beyoncé was outselling Madonna in 2003

    Doesn't mean she's bigger than Madonna overall

    Newer big artists will always do better than older artists

    You are ed

    you're basically saying bigger = more people know their name though, that's a weird way to define what "bigger" means.

    Bigger to me = more people care about what they're doing with their life/career. so for me Beyonce became bigger than Madonna in the 2000s

  • SWAN đź’ś
    Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    thegreatdivine

    No, she isn't and you'll see the next time Harry tours.

    He may very well prove to be a bigger touring act on his next tour, but based on their last tour numbers, Beyoncé is currently bigger

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    This is a great example of Beyoncé's reign.

    We are now comparing her to people that debuted in the late 2010s, exactly TWENTY YEARS after she debuted.

    Meanwhile her actual peers are all retired or tanked. Except P!nk.

    I remember how her "competitors" were people like Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera...

    I wonder if in the 2030s, we will be comparing her to someone that hasn't debuted yet.

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies
    jack johnson

    This is a great example of Beyoncé's reign.

    We are now comparing her to people that debuted in the late 2010s, exactly TWENTY YEARS after she debuted.

    Meanwhile her actual peers are all retired or tanked. Except P!nk.

    I remember how her "competitors" were people like Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera...

    I wonder if in the 2030s, we will be comparing her to someone that hasn't debuted yet.

    Fair but it's the same for TAylor v Beyonce comparisions then. Taylor and Harry basically debutted at the same time.

    legacy peaks also shouldn't matter for discussing who the biggest artist is. it makes no sense. Saying Ed Sheeran is bigger than The Weeknd for example would just feel wrong

  • Dec 4, 2024
  • Dec 4, 2024
  • Dec 4, 2024
    SWAN

    He may very well prove to be a bigger touring act on his next tour, but based on their last tour numbers, Beyoncé is currently bigger

    Fair enough.

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ANTI

    the blonde lady has them in shambles again!

    there is nothing funnier on this than how Taylor Swift RILES 'em up.

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    I swear you might d***ride weeknd more than thegreatdivine d***rides drake never seen you criticise anything about the weeknd ever

    This is not true. I’ve criticized him numerous times on here

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Come on man Taylor has literally almost the entire female population of the world obsessed with her lol. Beyonce never even had half her fanbase

    People barely care about Beyonce outside of the US. I actually think Taylor is 5x bigger than Beyonce outside of the US

    Imagine being this out of touch with reality

  • Dec 4, 2024

    Top o the mornin

Thread was locked by
a moderator