Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Dec 4, 2024
    mangotflu

    Fair but it's the same for TAylor v Beyonce comparisions then. Taylor and Harry basically debutted at the same time.

    legacy peaks also shouldn't matter for discussing who the biggest artist is. it makes no sense. Saying Ed Sheeran is bigger than The Weeknd for example would just feel wrong

    Ed Sheeran debuted 4 years before Weeknd reached the mainstream. That’s not the same as someone who has been around for 20 years before Taylor hit her peak

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Yeah I meant relative to her stature in the US

    There's a huge difference between doing like 12 stadium dates outside of the US vs what Taylor's doing with the Eras Tour

    it's nuts to compare them at this point

    the closest artist to Taylor is Adele and then Harry Styles tbh

    You really live your life through the lens of a stat sheet don’t you

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    You really live your life through the lens of a stat sheet don’t you

    you sound like an old person that still thinks artists like usher are big and on the radio lmao

  • Dec 4, 2024
    TheFader

    This is not true. I’ve criticized him numerous times on here

    nope

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Imagine being this out of touch with reality

    so you think beyonce is bigger than taylor outside of the US? Lol you really need to get out of the US

  • Dec 4, 2024

    Mariah you will pay for this

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    you sound like an old person that still thinks artists like usher are big and on the radio lmao

    Show me where I said this

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    so you think beyonce is bigger than taylor outside of the US? Lol you really need to get out of the US

    Beyonce is bigger than Taylor Swift.

    We’re talking about Beyonce for f***’s sake

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Show me where I said this

    You always say stats don't matter and "real life" matters more, which is exactly what old people say lol. Because they can't face the fact the world has changed. I've come to realise you're likely 40+ years old.

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Beyonce is bigger than Taylor Swift.

    We’re talking about Beyonce for f***’s sake

    In the US yes, outside no. Eras Tour in Europe/Asia is probably bigger than all of Beyonce's Europe/Asia tours combined thru her whole career lmao

  • Dec 4, 2024
    mangotflu

    You always say stats don't matter and "real life" matters more, which is exactly what old people say lol. Because they can't face the fact the world has changed. I've come to realise you're likely 40+ years old.

    I never said stats don’t matter.

    I said they are not the only thing that matters.

    Kanye, for example, is probably the most known figure in all of rap music and he doesn’t have the highest stats out of all rappers. There are numerous factors that contribute to an artist’s overall celebrity status, it’s not just raw numbers alone

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    In the US yes, outside no. Eras Tour in Europe/Asia is probably bigger than all of Beyonce's Europe/Asia tours combined thru her whole career lmao

    Yes because you saw one number bigger than the other and came to that conclusion

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Yes because you saw one number bigger than the other and came to that conclusion

    Ok so what could you possibly use to say Beyonce is bigger than Taylor in europe/asia? Lol your vibes?

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Ok so what could you possibly use to say Beyonce is bigger than Taylor in europe/asia? Lol your vibes?

    Maybe the fact that Beyonce has been a globally known and culturally relevant figure for the past 25 years and counting

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    Michael Jackson doesn’t have the highest grossing tour of all time btw. Is he not the most popular artist to ever walk the planet?

  • Dec 4, 2024
    TheFader

    Maybe the fact that Beyonce has been a globally known and culturally relevant figure for the past 25 years and counting

    Right & Taylor overtook her and is now bigger. it's that simple. Just like Ed Sheeran did too. Especially in Asia, Ed is far bigger in asia than almost anyone

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Michael Jackson doesn’t have the highest grossing tour of all time btw. Is he not the most popular artist to ever walk the planet?

    Sure so use # of tickets sold & Era Tour has still sold more tickets than all beyonce tours combined in europe/asia i think

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Sure so use # of tickets sold & Era Tour has still sold more tickets than all beyonce tours combined in europe/asia i think

    So is Taylor bigger than Michael Jackson as well?

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    So is Taylor bigger than Michael Jackson as well?

    Obviously not but she's the closest thing to MJ in the last 20+ years probably. Beyonce never had these crazy police escorts in foreign countries etc

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Obviously not but she's the closest thing to MJ in the last 20+ years probably. Beyonce never had these crazy police escorts in foreign countries etc

    But I thought numbers matter more than anything. MJ never did a tour that grossed over a billion like Taylor did. This must mean Taylor is bigger, no?

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    But I thought numbers matter more than anything. MJ never did a tour that grossed over a billion like Taylor did. This must mean Taylor is bigger, no?

    Using $ is stupid, I already said that. Everyone will tell you MJs tour were bigger than Taylor's.

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    Taylor destroys all of Beyonce's music sales (even peak Beyonce)

    destroys all her touring data

    destroys her networth

    yet people will still say she isnt bigger than her lol, weird

  • Dec 4, 2024
    mangotflu

    Using $ is stupid, I already said that. Everyone will tell you MJs tour were bigger than Taylor's.

    Even adjusted for inflation, MJ’s box office comes nowhere near a billion for one tour. Does that mean Taylor is bigger?

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Taylor destroys all of Beyonce's music sales (even peak Beyonce)

    destroys all her touring data

    destroys her networth

    yet people will still say she isnt bigger than her lol, weird

    Because not everything is about numbers

  • Dec 4, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Because not everything is about numbers

    Yeah vibes are more important

Thread was locked by
a moderator