That was oldheads hating on the young guys though. Remy wasn’t hating, she likes her music, just doesn’t view it as rap
yeah no
back when Drake, Future, and Thug we’re starting out, old heads would constantly say “yeah their music is dope but it’s not rap”
same exact thing here
i honestly don't even think you like her music
I genuinely do. I have Hot Pink on vinyl and I’m getting Planet Her when it comes out on Friday
Remy Ma’s was the opposite and y’all discredited it
it's almost like we shouldn't use the opinions of old heads and washed up racist institutions to form our views on art
it's almost like we shouldn't use the opinions of old heads and washed up racist institutions to form our views on art
Wale is washed up and irrelevant so his opinion doesn’t matter either then
no one said this
That's what I'm getting from this Convo idk maybe I'm seeing it wrong.
they said the exact same thing about Drake, Future, and Thug a decade ago
Two diff things cause no one woulda had made a clear distinction as what they were vs. us saying that Doja makes Pop music
It’s not hating. Nuance is a thing. Not everything is black and white.
I love Doja Cat’s music but I don’t view her as a rapper. Is that hating too?
the only reason for you not viewing her as a rapper its because of her current success and thats it
you can give a thousand reasons but the real reason is that she's selling more than your fave
Wale is washed up and irrelevant so his opinion doesn’t matter either then
yeah, no s***
you and the other dumbasses cited remy ma as a hip hop legend that somehow verifies this whole "she's not a rapper" shtick as accepted fact, nobody gives a f*** about what she has to say
She made a record so that makes her a rapper. That's what you guys are saying. Unless you hate women.
That’s literally what they’re saying
“She rapped on these songs so she’s a rapper, if you disagree you hate women or you’re salty that she’s outselling your favs”
Ohhhhhhhhhh, ok, now I understand

yeah, no s***
you and the other dumbasses cited remy ma as a hip hop legend that somehow verifies this whole "she's not a rapper" shtick as accepted fact, nobody gives a f*** about what she has to say
And nobody gives a f*** about what Wale has to say but you backed it up like it meant something
I’m tired of pretending pop doesn’t have its own genre ethos + traditional sounds
When a song has a sung melody with production that mixes genre influences to the point of its primary genre being ambiguous? It’s a pop song.
Traditionally this would be in dance music comprised of a mix of: rock, r&b, funk, disco in whatever variations
So let’s keep this in mind
When a song has a sung melody with production that mixes genre influences to the point of its primary genre being ambiguous? It’s a pop song.
need something in here to distinguish obviously non-pop/anti-commercial type genre mixing ambiguous stuff in here then i could agree
One song. Let’s see her doing freestyles, or let’s see her interview on vlad tv detailing her origins as a rapper, or lets see that song Ariana grande made with space ghost Purrp
I understand that she raps. But all those things can't be what makes someone a rapper.
First test is what kind of music do you make. Never heard on her on a Metro beat, nothing like that.
That's what I'm getting from this Convo idk maybe I'm seeing it wrong.
i've been saying this entire time that all of her work even dating back from her actual studio album days have primarily featured rapping on it
this makes her a rapper, regardless of the style of production that she is on
it doesn't matter what songs of hers charts, it doesn't matter what style of music she pursues, she has rapped since she first came out
Ohhhhhhhhhh, ok, now I understand

Please keep bringing up everything but her music as to why we say she's a Pop artist
Ohhhhhhhhhh, ok, now I understand

This narrative has been pushed on every other page and I keep saying this has nothing to do with Drake. I’ve been listening to Doja for years now and I’ve never viewed her as a rapper
I understand that she raps. But all those things can't be what makes someone a rapper.
First test is what kind of music do you make. Never heard on her on a Metro beat, nothing like that.
so we define rappers as to whether or not they use a f***ing metro beat?
I understand that she raps. But all those things can't be what makes someone a rapper.
First test is what kind of music do you make. Never heard on her on a Metro beat, nothing like that.
She’s a rapper who makes r&b and pop music
She dabbles in multiple genres like Trippie red
Please keep bringing up everything but her music as to why we say she's a Pop artist
I posted plenty of her music already in this thread and you didn’t respond, but I knew this would get you.
so we define rappers as to whether or not they use a f***ing metro beat?
He was clearly giving an example