That Fantano review was most probably not even that much of a big thing for the Kanye community. Kanye fans normally don't fw Fantano, at least not when it comes to Kanye reviews. That MBDTF review was pretty much the dealbreaker for most Kanye fans. So I don't know what you're talking about.
I think it's the first time since MBDTF he had an idea, he knew completely how he wanted to execute it, and he fully developed it. There are so many different elements in the lyrics. You get a sense of how manic he is with his abrupt "grat tat tat"s in Feel the Love, to his more calm self confidence in Fire, to his coming to terms with his s***addiction on 4th Dimension, to his super elevated level on Freee (one end of the bipolar spectrum), to his more depressed state on Reborn where he discusses his struggles, to his self reflection and inflated egoism that makes Kanye Kanye on the title track but also with a hint of recognition of his flaws, to finally an outward-looking perspective that Kanye takes on the world around him on Cudi Montage where he revisits his spirituality. It's a holistic representation of Kanye's mental state over the past few years. We even get a self aware Kanye who embraces the meme of "Scoop!" from Lift Yourself on Freee, suggesting he's at a point where he doesn't always have to take himself so seriously all the time.
And the album is filled with cool lines like his 4 bars on Cudi Montage where he plays with difference meanings of "peace" and "piece," his art references on Kids See Ghosts, his "I won't finish the sent-" line on 4th Dimension, etc. And then you get a ton of different deliveries and flows from Ye across the album, as well. He raps in a way that seems "off beat" on the title track, but really he's just putting together his rhymes at even points in the time signature rather than odd. He sings on Freee. He seamlessly switches up his flow on 4th Dimension. He gives us some great sounding lines with assonance on 4th Dimension. And on Cudi Montage we just get a cutthroat traditional rap from Kanye.
It's so cool because the whole album is Kanye working with Cudi through his mental health struggles and ending up in a place where he can take a look at the issues that are bigger than himself. Now, he's done changing himself and he's comfortable in his own skin, and it's time to address all the violence and inequality in the world. Also, I haven't even mentioned how consistently great and variable the production is while still maintaining its psychedelic vibe. Or how fantastic Cudi's contributions are, who focuses more on the recovery aspect than the struggle aspect that Kanye focuses on.
It's a perfect album to me, and it honestly blows me away still how meticulously crafted it is. It's one you really have to just sit down with a good pair of headphones and fully immerse yourself in for its 23 minute run time that manages to feel a lot longer because of how dense and substantive it is.
this is why i believe ksg is a perfect 10/10 classic. it upsets me people dont see its greatness
What is the legitimate reason that people on KTT trash this album? That’s your opinion but I’m just curious.
Personally, I think it’s literally a flawless album from start to finish. It’s a shorter album than JIK yet it feels complete and it’s feels like a real album.
How long did it take for Kanye and Cudi to make this? Sounds like it took a year and a lot of actual effort rather than Kanye f***ing around.
That s*** mid
Why do you think that. Did you read the nerd essays in this thread