Reply
  • Updated Dec 22, 2019

    Hello all,

    I thought it would be fun to have a game of the decade competition similar to this YouTube series:

    Basically everyone who participates nominates one game per year for 2010-2019 and the top 5 games with the most votes for each year will be chosen to compete in anonymous polls against games of the same year. Then the winner of each year will be chosen to move on to the game of the decade round. Each round would have 24 hours to vote. Initial nominations will be open for 3 days or so. Game of the decade round would consist of the winners from each year and go head to head. Not entirely sure how to do the GOTD round but I’m thinking 3 rounds going from 10->5->2 and the winner being decided from the top 2. I’m open to suggestions for GOTD rounds.

    A few rules: Release year will be going by US initial Release Date. So Persona 5 is 2017 not 2016. Enchanted ports do not count. For example, Persona 4 Golden is not eligible and Mario Kart 8 must be nominated in initial release year and Deluxe can not be nominated. Complete remakes like Resident Evil 2 are fine. We will not be going by The Game Awards nomination cycle so December games count for the year they were released in. All of these rules are the same rules used in the youtube series I posted above so don’t shoot the messenger.

    If people are interested in this I think it would be fun to do and we can see what game comes out as KTT’s game of the decade.

    If interested, nominate 1 game per year:
    2010-
    2011-
    2012-
    2013-
    2014-
    2015-
    2016-
    2017-
    2018-
    2019-

    If this flops, oh well, it only took 5 minutes to make this thread.

    Voting is now in session: surveymonkey.com/r/XBSHGRP

  • Dec 18, 2019

    2010 - Mass Effect 2
    2011 - Dark Souls
    2012 - Diablo 3
    2013 - Grand Theft Auto 5
    2014 - Mario Kart 8
    2015 - Bloodborne
    2016 - Dark Souls 3
    2017 - Hollow Knight
    2018 - Monster Hunter World
    2019 - Sekiro

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    4 replies

    10 red dead redemption
    11 skyrim
    12 dishonored
    13 pokemon xy
    14 mario kart 8
    15 super mario maker / undertale / phantom pain / rocket league
    16 overwatch
    17breath of the wild / odyssey
    18 ssb ultimate
    19 untitled goose game / luigis mansion 3

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply

    2010- Heavy Rain
    2011- Uncharted 3
    2012- Borderlands 2
    2013- The Last Of Us
    2014- Mario Kart 8
    2015- Rocket League
    2016- Pokémon Sun/Moon
    2017- Super Mario Odyssey
    2018- Super Smash Bros Ultimate
    2019- Luigi's Manson 3 (Resident Evil 2 was here but I'm giving the edge to LM3 for being new and not a remake)

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    gnocchi

    10 red dead redemption
    11 skyrim
    12 dishonored
    13 pokemon xy
    14 mario kart 8
    15 super mario maker / undertale / phantom pain / rocket league
    16 overwatch
    17breath of the wild / odyssey
    18 ssb ultimate
    19 untitled goose game / luigis mansion 3

    Can only pick one per year

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    Luca

    Can only pick one per year

    ok pick one for me

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    gnocchi

    ok pick one for me

    No, you must pick

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    Luca

    No, you must pick

    I did I picked them

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    gnocchi

    I did I picked them

    If I had to pick from those years I’d pick Rocket League, Super Mario Odyssey, and Luigi’s Mansion 3 from what you have listed.

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    Luca

    If I had to pick from those years I’d pick Rocket League, Super Mario Odyssey, and Luigi’s Mansion 3 from what you have listed.

    you right, I love those games in 2015 but rocket league is deffo not going anywhere

  • Dec 18, 2019

    Idk but Skyrim the game of the decade

  • Dec 18, 2019
    gnocchi

    you right, I love those games in 2015 but rocket league is deffo not going anywhere

    Edit your post please

    Or else it won’t count

  • Dec 18, 2019

    2010 - Red Dead Redemption
    2011 - Skyrim
    2012 - Black Ops II
    2013 - Battlefield 4
    2014 - Insurgency
    2015 - The Witcher III
    2016 - Firewatch
    2017 - Fortnite

    Haven't played any new games in the past 2 years to vote for those

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    edited

    2010- Alan Wake
    2011- Dota 2
    2012- Far Cry 3
    2013- GTA 5
    2014- Alien Isolation
    2015- Dying Light
    2016- Hitman
    2017- Battlefront II
    2018- Spider-Man
    2019- Apex Legends

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    2 replies

    Hmmm, not sure if I should count incomplete lists

    Why y’all in the videogame section if you haven’t played videogames for 2 years?

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    Luca

    Hmmm, not sure if I should count incomplete lists

    Why y’all in the videogame section if you haven’t played videogames for 2 years?

    Maybe they can’t decide in just one from said year

  • Dec 18, 2019
    World1

    Maybe they can’t decide in just one from said year

    If it’s hard to pick you still need to pick one game. Even if it’s just flipping a coin between two games for the sake of picking one.

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply

    2010- Super Mario Galaxy 2
    2011- Zelda SS
    2012- Crusader Kings 2
    2013- Pandora's Tower
    2014- Mario kart 8
    2015- Monster Hunter generations
    2016- Disgaea 5 (Persona 5)
    2017-BOTW
    2018- Smash Bros Ultimate
    2019-Luigi Mansion 3

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    272Coz
    · edited

    2010- Super Mario Galaxy 2
    2011- Zelda SS
    2012- Crusader Kings 2
    2013- Pandora's Tower
    2014- Mario kart 8
    2015- Monster Hunter generations
    2016- Disgaea 5 (Persona 5)
    2017-BOTW
    2018- Smash Bros Ultimate
    2019-Luigi Mansion 3

    Persona 5 is ineligible for 2016 because it came out in US in 2017.

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    Luca

    Persona 5 is ineligible for 2016 because it came out in US in 2017.

    changed

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    272Coz

    changed

    But you can use Persona 5 for 2017 if you wish

  • Dec 18, 2019
    Luca

    But you can use Persona 5 for 2017 if you wish

    I don't want to make it even harder to chose 2017 goty

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    Luca

    Hmmm, not sure if I should count incomplete lists

    Why y’all in the videogame section if you haven’t played videogames for 2 years?

    i haven't played any game in 2018/2019 that i'd qualify as goty.

    but if you want i can put some s*** for those years just so it counts, even though i wont think those games are the goty

  • Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    1 reply
    SlappyBag

    i haven't played any game in 2018/2019 that i'd qualify as goty.

    but if you want i can put some s*** for those years just so it counts, even though i wont think those games are the goty

    What’s your favorite games of those years. That’s all it really is. Out of the games you’ve played from those years, which did you like best.

  • lucid 🌹
    Dec 18, 2019
    ·
    edited

    2010: red dead redemption
    2011: skyrim
    2012: borderlands 2
    2013: shadow warrior
    2014: binding of isaac: rebirth
    2015: bloodborne
    2016: darkest dungeon
    2017: mario odyssey
    2018: dragon ball fighterz
    2019: sekiro

1
2
...
13