I think part of the point of this comparison is they’re not directly comparable, that almost makes it funnier

Madvillainy vs Pinata is no fun

Super close tbh. Be has probably Kanye’s best production for another artist ever.

All time before? Probably top 100. I liked some of his stuff but I never made the effort to really give him my full attention.

Now? Top 15 easily.

Dude has a discography as good as Kendrick, Ye, OutKast etc.

He has 2 misses out of 12-13 albums I've heard so far. Thats f***ing nuts.

Madvillainy has 22 tracks and 10 of them are interludes

Yeah but they are more listenable than the bs skits on MM FOOD

Damn bro I hate it had to be you

Please delete your account for this stupid s***, this is just too far

There should be a rule where you get banned for stupid s*** like this

Fair, I’m just saying

The songs on Food are better tho

no way lol

They are very good, but I'll always be mad at DOOM for not making it flow like a normal album

Be

pinata is better than madvillainy btw

Yeah if you wear Adidas tracksuits

I think the Madvillain vs Piñata comparison is cliche and not very interesting. Because even though Piñata is f***ing great, 95% of us are gonna choose Madvillian.

Be and Madvillian are both undisputed classics. And you really have to think before you choose one if you have heard both. They're both masterpieces and both bring amazing qualities to the table.

Yeah agreed

Maybe if you combined piñata and bandana you might have case

the breaths on point asf😂😂😂

need a exquire album also

I can understand that

But I’m also someone who is really big on albums flowing well

And I don’t feel like the skit intermission is that bad, it’s unique

How would you have sequenced the album? I question if the album would have been better without the skits, I feel like for a concept this weird it works and just the 10 best tracks approach wouldn’t have worked as well

Yeah lol that might’ve ruined Gibbs for me

Maybe just fewer/shorter skits and maybe add some better background instrumentals to them to make them less boring to sit through

At one point you sit through 3 skits in a row like

S*** was funny NGL but Imma still bump his s*** like normal. If memes and social media dictated my music taste, I probably would've stopped listening to Drake a long time ago.

Meek Mill takes the hardest hit in that regard

Uhhhhhhhhhhhhh

All the skits are happening over instrumentals, there’s no pure skits, only doom beats with vocal samples on top

Yikes I shouldn’t have asked, thought you knew what you were talking about

Lmao you not wrong I’m mostly playing, I still love Gibbs flow

But even before that meme I did kind of start to feel like his flow became a little too predictable and samey. It’s a great flow but it’s similar on most tracks and the breathing kinda sucks too

Yeah but when did anyone ever go "Yeah he's a good f***ing rapper who makes good music...but his breathing though. Man he doesn't breathe right on the beat."