Jan 16, 2023I’d put Dak in that tier as well
Jan 16, 2023·1 reply
bigbeltsNo, you are still looking at it on a 1 for 1. They aren't moving on from carr because of just last year but because of his ENTIRE tenure. If carr won a sb last year do you think they cut him? No.
And I'm not advocating for cousins to be cut but he is who he is just like carr is.
that silly hypothetical did not happen though.
just to play that game, if Carr won a SB 5 years ago, would that have prevented him from being cut? idts. so idk the hypothetical game is silly to me. he was cut because he's won nothing meaningful and had a s*** last season lmao. i think we both agree nonetheless tho.- Jan 16, 2023·1 reply
UnityWe've talked all year in here about how trash the QB situation is around the league and y'all want the Vikings to move on from 66% completion percentage, 4500 yards and 29 TDs because he couldn't win a game where his defense forced 0 turnovers and 1 punt
Brilliant
Nobody is advocating for that truly lol ain't he already locked up for 3 years
- Jan 16, 2023·1 replyhoopsplayer21
that silly hypothetical did not happen though.
just to play that game, if Carr won a SB 5 years ago, would that have prevented him from being cut? idts. so idk the hypothetical game is silly to me. he was cut because he's won nothing meaningful and had a s*** last season lmao. i think we both agree nonetheless tho.The only thing of importance is that he hasn't won anything after a long career. Who does that sound like
- Unity 💯Jan 16, 2023·1 replybigbelts
The only thing of importance is that he hasn't won anything after a long career. Who does that sound like
Sounds like every QB in the league not named Brady, Rodgers, Wilson, Mahomes, and Stafford
- Unity 💯Jan 16, 2023bigbelts
Nobody is advocating for that truly lol ain't he already locked up for 3 years
No, only through next year where he'll be making a base salary of 10 million dollars
- Jan 16, 2023·1 replyUnity
Sounds like every QB in the league not named Brady, Rodgers, Wilson, Mahomes, and Stafford
How many of them been in the league for a decade
- Unity 💯Jan 16, 2023
That dead cap is the killer
Jan 16, 2023·1 replyovocrewWho’s the young QB?
I'd say Kyler
It's also early in his career still, TLaw might not hit an elite level, but we'll see I'm not gonna tier him at this stage yet
But also is great the same as elite in your eyes?
- Unity 💯Jan 16, 2023·1 replybigbelts
How many of them been in the league for a decade
The only QBs who were on rosters capable of winning it all for a decade are Brady Rodgers and Wilson
- Jan 16, 2023Ōzaru Nayuta
I'd say Kyler
It's also early in his career still, TLaw might not hit an elite level, but we'll see I'm not gonna tier him at this stage yet
But also is great the same as elite in your eyes?
Agreed on Kyler, and I think Lawrence will be in that tier this time next year
For me there’s a “very good tier” right in between elite and “good” but I think figuring out where you’d put some of these guys in these tiers is really really tough sometimes
Jan 16, 2023·3 repliesExamples for me: Lamar and Herbert are great, you got Allen and Burrow as elite, then Mahomes is just Mahomes
Jan 16, 2023·4 repliesBucs Nation!!!
- Jan 16, 2023·3 repliesJulio Caesar
Examples for me: Lamar and Herbert are great, you got Allen and Burrow as elite, then Mahomes is just Mahomes
See I agree with all of this, but I think there’s a good amount of fans that would put Herbert in that elite tier
- Jan 16, 2023
Lamar too^
- Jan 16, 2023Unity
The only QBs who were on rosters capable of winning it all for a decade are Brady Rodgers and Wilson
- Jan 16, 2023·2 repliesovocrew
See I agree with all of this, but I think there’s a good amount of fans that would put Herbert in that elite tier
I feel like they do that for him as a QB talent, me I'm mixing talent with results when I'm ranking QBs
- Jan 16, 2023Julio Caesar
I feel like they do that for him as a QB talent, me I'm mixing talent with results when I'm ranking QBs
Exactly
- Jan 16, 2023·1 replyovocrew
See I agree with all of this, but I think there’s a good amount of fans that would put Herbert in that elite tier
Can't be elite until he has that signature run imo
Jan 16, 2023·1 replyhoopsplayer21gotta be DJ atp
Nah he's in the great tier 💯
- Jan 16, 2023BilI Ackman
Nah he's in the great tier 💯
sorry man it's giants hate week now. F*** Daboll's groundhog looking ass.
- Jan 16, 2023bigbelts
Can't be elite until he has that signature run imo
I need to see him take another leap before I put him in that elite tier, it could definitely happen with the right coach but he’s just not there yet imo
- Unity 💯Jan 16, 2023·2 repliesJulio Caesar
I feel like they do that for him as a QB talent, me I'm mixing talent with results when I'm ranking QBs
A lot of Herbert's bad results are on Staley and Lombardi though
- Unity 💯Jan 16, 2023
Herbert is really the only guy people consider elite that also has an objectively bad HC
A testament to his unreal talent level
Jan 16, 2023·1 replyovocrewSee I agree with all of this, but I think there’s a good amount of fans that would put Herbert in that elite tier
If Herbert was elite he would’ve won that game on Saturday.
He’ll get there though.
