Reply
  • Oct 25, 2020
    iHype

    Biggie was already one of the most iconic names in Hip-Hop history. The genre was still relatively new unlike R&B.

    What about Tlc Then? They not legends?

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    FKA STUFF

    Dude that’s what legendary means

    You’re mixing your words

    No. People consider MJ, Prince, etc HUGE legends before they died.

    Aaliyah is someone who would've never been considered a legend at the time in 2001 by anyone whatsoever.

  • Oct 25, 2020
    FKA STUFF

    Damn

    Nation

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    iHype

    No. People consider MJ, Prince, etc HUGE legends before they died.

    Aaliyah is someone who would've never been considered a legend at the time in 2001 by anyone whatsoever.

    Stop qualifying legends lmfaooo

    She’s a legend by definition

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply

    Man said “huge legends” like the history books give a f***

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    iHype

    Brandy & Aaliyah didn't have longevity

    Mariah/Mary/R. Kelly/Usher/etc have classics spanning 20~ years.

    Brandy don't even got classics past the first 2 albums, and Aaliyah died way too early on before she got anywhere near legends discussion.

    I think they're both moreso icons.

    Does commercial longevity really matter when discussing legend status though?

    I mean, Bobby Brown only had one true classic and another hit album and was done as a solo act, but his impact on rnb makes him a legend.

    Brandy and Aaliyah both dropped 3 classics, and while they either didn't make it (Aaliyah) or their new music wasn't as impactful (Brandy) the music they made when they were on top are timeless classics that influenced the next generation of rnb artists. I think musical longevity should be a factor too.

  • Oct 25, 2020
    iHype

    No. People consider MJ, Prince, etc HUGE legends before they died.

    Aaliyah is someone who would've never been considered a legend at the time in 2001 by anyone whatsoever.

    Theres so many legends that arent MJ or Prince tier lol wtf

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    FKA STUFF

    Man said “huge legends” like the history books give a f***

    Depends who's writing them

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Goo

    Depends who's writing them

    Not that nigga that’s for sure

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    FKA STUFF

    Not that nigga that’s for sure

    Technically he can publish one

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    FKA STUFF

    Stop qualifying legends lmfaooo

    She’s a legend by definition

    Aaliyah was 22. She was still really young and hadn't truly PROVEN herself yet, she was just getting there.

    That's like if Ariana Grande died or something.

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    beast444

    "sorry ass list"

    90s legends but no mention of Keith sweat, Johnny Gill, Ginuwine or Jodeci

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Goo

    Technically he can publish one

    Would you read it?

  • Oct 25, 2020
    FKA STUFF

    Would you read it?

    Well.. no I wouldn't

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    stingray

    90s legends but no mention of Keith sweat, Johnny Gill, Ginuwine or Jodeci

    If you’re adding Keith, you’re adding Janet...

  • Oct 25, 2020
    FKA STUFF

    If you’re adding Keith, you’re adding Janet...

    Janet killing everybody 💯

  • Oct 25, 2020
    beast444

    Does commercial longevity really matter when discussing legend status though?

    I mean, Bobby Brown only had one true classic and another hit album and was done as a solo act, but his impact on rnb makes him a legend.

    Brandy and Aaliyah both dropped 3 classics, and while they either didn't make it (Aaliyah) or their new music wasn't as impactful (Brandy) the music they made when they were on top are timeless classics that influenced the next generation of rnb artists. I think musical longevity should be a factor too.

    New Edition was relevant for well over a decade alone.

    Brandy literally doesn't have no type of classic or big remembered moment after her 2nd album. You are really pushing it considering her a legend lol.

  • Oct 25, 2020

    Brandy gotta go

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    FKA STUFF

    If you’re adding Keith, you’re adding Janet...

    Keith and Jodeci are far superior

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    stingray

    Keith and Jodeci are far superior

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply

    Niggas preferring male rnb over woman rnb always be blowing minds

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    stingray

    Keith and Jodeci are far superior

    My point is them debuting in the 80s should rule them out of this

    Ginuwine is a good addition and sure Jodeci if we’re going for groups

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    mr get dough

    Niggas preferring male rnb over woman rnb always be blowing minds

    It depends who.

    Usher is obviously better than Brandy/Aaliyah/Monica.

    Beyonce wipes the floor with any male who debuted this century though.

  • Oct 25, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    mr get dough

    Keith is responsible for helping birth at least 70 percent of ktt users

  • Oct 25, 2020
    iHype

    It depends who.

    Usher is obviously better than Brandy/Aaliyah/Monica.

    Beyonce wipes the floor with any male who debuted this century though.

    I just mean in general not like every woman is better than every man