They've dropped their list:
pitchfork.com/features/lists-and-guides/best-songs-2023

Top 10 for those that are too lazy:
10. Earl Sweatshirt - Making the Band
9. Troye Sivan - Rush
8. Wednesday - Chosen to Deserve
7. NewJeans - Super Shy
6. SZA - Kill Bill
5. Olivia Rodrigo - Get Him Back!
4. Noname - Namesake
3. Sufjan Stevens - Will Anybody Ever Love Me?
2. PinkPantheress & Ice Spice - Boy’s a liar Pt. 2
1. Lana Del Rey - A&W

Kinda mid list tbh

GTA 6 trailer boutta drop and you link a Pitchfork article

will be mid, just like the p4k list tbh

Luh Tyler Flow shoulda been #1

controversy!

their top 10 is already better than Rolling Stone's, namesake let me dig in

I don't ever agree with these lists but listening to the playlist is always good for finding stuff I've never heard of tbh

ASAKE on another Best Of list. 2023 MVP MR. MONEYYY

trash

Real af for Making the Band in the top 10. Earl floated.

pretty in possible #60 few different songs from that Caroline album that could go here

edit: she got I Believe at #19 too

Rush is trash. That Olivia track isn’t very good either

Sampha's Spirit 2.0 at #49. Lahai will probably be higher on Pitchfork's list than the other ones that have come out so far, i know a lot of people were upset over that

Tinashe's Needs at #46 A BOP

I was bouta say list was absolutely worthless if it didn't have Thank Allah on it, and there it is

They added “Fentanyl Tester” by JPEG & Danny Brown but that's not even the best song on SCARING THE HOES

Could name 5 songs off that album that are better and more deserving lol

Only songs I liked from here are rush, making the band, super shy, Kill Bill, and boys a liar pt 2

Victoria Monét's On My Mama #30, A BOP she's been getting so many looks this year

nourished by time number 11

no drake, no travis and no the weeknd?

Namesake getting love >
That s*** went off live....people were singing the words

AMAARAE - CO-STAR #16 FOUNTAIN BABY OUT NOW

EROTIC PROBIOTIC 2 OUT NOW, CATCHING CHICKENS EP OTW

You know P4K is finally cooked if their #1 song of 2023 is a Lana Del Rey song

You're right but I'm not mad that Kelis sample is undeniable & this song sounds nothing else like rap in 23