first page is a cesspool, why are so many people proud of being too stupid to read a couple paragraphs of text

i genuinely dont get it

lol

man

End of Transmission

also music discussion is inherently flawed due 2 the nature of the subject

there’s no concept of objectivity n letting the same public that redacted
be the arbiter of such things is groupthink

End of Transmission

🌽 🏀

End of transmission

nah, I don't like this. When you start making tier list for classic level albums, it gives leeway for mediocrity to be called classics.

literally

Illmatic and The Chronic are both in the Library of Congres how are they not undisputed

Because OP somehow thinks The Chronic and Illmatic arent on the same level as S.O.C

where is the lie?

what does that even mean? an album that is immediately gassed by KTT 5 min after release only to be forgotten a couple years later?

if it's actually classic, it will remain after the immediate moment. that is the test of time.

Definitely

The actual tiers are pretty well done though

For example I’d put Take Care at Level 1 and NWTS at Level 2, imo

You can find more people that don't like an "instant classic" than the people who like said classic, so what does that make it?

Music is nuanced

Nah bruh, there's only a classic album, period, then a trash album, also period

I feel like the reason OP only put straight outta compton on that level and not illmatic, the chronic, doggystyle, all eyez on me, etc is because of how controversial it was. Idk if I agree with that logic

Op posting these DUSTY BOOMER albums for examples smh where is WLR in tier 1???

There’s only 3 hiphop albums from the 2010s in that first level. Y’all can figure out what those are

Everyone knew MBDTF was a classic when it dropped

thanks OP.

makes me sad there hasn’t been a first tier classic yet this decade

I like this too

Yes

Ain’t reading all that bro, but I know if the hood ain’t playing it it ain’t a classic, period.

I think that the one thing I dislike the most about these discussions is the overemphasis on old ass music

like especially in rap it’s perpetually niggas hating n b****ing on present day s***

n then they turn around n begrudgingly f*** wit it years later

End of Transmission