Is Garth Brooks' catalog not canon because it's not on streaming?

the amount of coping around Donda 2 is ridiculous

I remember riding for Nah Nah Nah so hard when it dropped that even my friends who love Ye were like damn bro chill this sucks

Wait a second that was a dumb statement, I forgot about mixtapes and s***

donda 2 is a tape but this logic is insane when little wayne exists

I think he means stuff released in the modern era

Yeah I wasn’t thinking

JIK is a miss but it's still okay, just mediocre

Donda 2 a whole miss

It's a demo

Donda 2 literally got incomplete verses and never was updated, why would you count it in his discog?

He really doesn’t. Only actual miss that’s consensus is JIK and even that has its fans

It’s mostly just a beat tape with a bunch of mumbling
Why would anyone count that? 😂 It’s not cope, I just feel like you’re being extra if you include that s***

• Days Before Rodeo
• A s***load of Screw tapes
• Damn near every Memphis rap release recorded between 1988-1996
• A lot of old punk records
• A lot of old dance records

Streaming being the authority of the canon would only make sense if the musical canon developed simultaneously and as a byproduct of the advent of streaming, which is objectively not true and couldn't be true

XTCY = great production, topic is funny
ye vs the people = great production, topic is trash
Lift Yourself = troll song, great production

And multiple songs were given to other artists

Lift Yourself is a classic and XTCY beat i amazing

Ye Vs. The People kinda sucked tbh

Yeah, that’s why I really gotta think things through before posting

no worries brudda just shining a light

production on ye vs the people is amazing, it's a shame that he used it for this hogwash

Bigger travesty than lift yourself, had that fire beat to talk over it in a surface level political debate with TI

I wasn't honestly that impressed by the production

I actually think the subject matter on XTCY is more repulsive than Ye Vs. The People

The guy who made "Family Business" knows better

No they really can’t. TLOP is one of his most popular and beloved albums. Yeezus was well received critically and has proven to be influential a decade later. Outside of ktt Ye was well received