Because we already have seen a a better performance in game
Game Ellie literally just sits at Joel’s grave for like 10 seconds and leaves. There’s no dialogue or anything.
Anyone who had a problem with the grave scene in the show is just nitpicking for no reason

Game Ellie literally just sits at Joel’s grave for like 10 seconds and leaves. There’s no dialogue or anything.
Anyone who had a problem with the grave scene in the show is just nitpicking for no reason

People are really just looking for any reasons to complain about Bella and hoping something works
Game Ellie literally just sits at Joel’s grave for like 10 seconds and leaves. There’s no dialogue or anything.
Anyone who had a problem with the grave scene in the show is just nitpicking for no reason

Im talkin bout the whole damn show
What was wrong with her performance at the grave?
Also I thought Bella did great in the scene with Joel’s jacket
I liked the jacket too
The sentiment behind the grave scene is good (the coffee beans) but idk felt a bit flat
The grave scene felt like it was a callback to that season 1 episode with the deaf/mute kid, specifically the ending. And I don't see what's exactly wrong with Bella's performance. I've never seen an actress get this microanalyzed before lol
It didn’t land for me and that’s okay. Everyone’s view of that scene will be different but I’m not gonna praise Bella just for the sake of it. She had good moments otherwise. Her facial expressions in that scene were ehhhh.
Also if this is how we’re gonna be, what can we actually comment on? It’s getting ridiculous on both sides. I get she’s been trolled but we’re not doing that here
His motivation to go to seattle
What the therapist said? It’s mildly interesting but I hope it doesn’t remove the edge off his character. But it remains to be seen
It didn’t land for me and that’s okay. Everyone’s view of that scene will be different but I’m not gonna praise Bella just for the sake of it. She had good moments otherwise. Her facial expressions in that scene were ehhhh.
Also if this is how we’re gonna be, what can we actually comment on? It’s getting ridiculous on both sides. I get she’s been trolled but we’re not doing that here
It most definitely has been happening here lmao
It didn’t land for me and that’s okay. Everyone’s view of that scene will be different but I’m not gonna praise Bella just for the sake of it. She had good moments otherwise. Her facial expressions in that scene were ehhhh.
Also if this is how we’re gonna be, what can we actually comment on? It’s getting ridiculous on both sides. I get she’s been trolled but we’re not doing that here
You mean rn or on ktt? Cus there was a post a couple of pages back that was so flagrant I just had to laugh.
As for Bella, I mean, you ain't gotta like her performance if you don't, but the trolls make it hard for a genuine back and forth
What the therapist said? It’s mildly interesting but I hope it doesn’t remove the edge off his character. But it remains to be seen
he should have been there with Joel instead of Dina
he should have been there with Joel instead of Dina
I think it was changed to directly address complaints from “gamers”
Dina yelling out Joel is a more plausible way for Abby to figure out Joel’s name. And her being there gives Dina way more of a reason to go with Ellie for Joel than in the game where she just goes to keep Ellie company
Tommy was always gonna go cause Joel is family and you bet your ass Tommy probably following behind. I don’t mind the change
I think it was changed to directly address complaints from “gamers”
Dina yelling out Joel is a more plausible way for Abby to figure out Joel’s name. And her being there gives Dina way more of a reason to go with Ellie for Joel than in the game where she just goes to keep Ellie company
Tommy was always gonna go cause Joel is family and you bet your ass Tommy probably following behind. I don’t mind the change
They removed an integral part imo. They’re good writers, they could have figured out a way around the whole revealing who they are without this round about way.
he should have been there with Joel instead of Dina
They wanted to give dina a reasonable motive to go to seattle, tommy is his fkin brother he already has one
Ok so it sounds like they are going to reverse the roles. Tommy is going to go after Ellie, instead of Ellie going after him
Seems like the writers want Tommy to be more caring and thoughtful in the show adaptation. I’m really curious to see how they’ll handle the scene of Tommy showing up at Ellie and Dina’s place and trying to convince her to go after Abby again. I can’t imagine this Tommy doing something like that, but maybe after him and Jesse are shot it will change him as a person. Also it would be even more heartbreaking to see this Tommy take that dark turn because of how caring he is right now
Ok so it sounds like they are going to reverse the roles. Tommy is going to go after Ellie, instead of Ellie going after him
https://twitter.com/thelastofusnews/status/1918024785356853696I mean Tommy's a good dude, but he ain't Joel nahmean
Seems like the writers want Tommy to be more caring and thoughtful in the show adaptation. I’m really curious to see how they’ll handle the scene of Tommy showing up at Ellie and Dina’s place and trying to convince her to go after Abby again. I can’t imagine this Tommy doing something like that, but maybe after him and Jesse are shot it will change him as a person. Also it would be even more heartbreaking to see this Tommy take that dark turn because of how caring he is right now
Yess exactly. How he is now COULD be setting up that moment really well.
We will see him get rotted from the inside out by that anger vengeance feeling. and we will see him go from someone who was willing to let Abby go, to someone who visits Ellie and Dina years later and shames Ellie into going to get Abby
Lots of this season really feels like the creatives tweaking elements in small ways earlier on, so that when certain moments happen later on, they hit in more nuanced ways
It's over
Changes absolutely nothing cause Tommy never acknowledges it ever besides the intro cutscene lmfao
lmao some of you are never getting rid of the OG material bias
Casting did a terrible job and there's nothing she can do to redeem this fact