I called this trash from the 1st episode and never went back

They called me a madman and said its a slow buildup

Now everyone is calling it the worst finale of all time

“Because it’s about women, you think the new season is bad?”

YOU’RE NOT ASKING THE RIGHT QUESTION! ASK AGAIN! 😡🤬

“Uh, why do the murders and mine pollution matter if everybody comes back as a ghost and its pretty well known around town that there’s a vivid, complex life after death?”

Now we’re getting somewhere 🫵😎

"If you depict police as valiant social workers who protect women and commit political violence on the right side of the class war- why are they still alienated from the community, unfulfilled, and miserable?"

"Is leaving your few remaining friends, quitting your job as indigenous praetorian guard, and going on a quasi-suicidal spirit quest a positive outcome?"

"Is murdering your dad something that will improve your mental health?"

"Would a sheriff's deputy be better at hiding forensic evidence than 50 janitors?"

"If your mom was kind of racist to you, but she was in danger one night, would you guys be cool after?"

Sepinwall is such a hack

Night Country basically just ripped off the twist and ending of Wind River

overall bad season but last two eps redeemed it back to decent. Enjoyed the finale but understand why everybody is hating

I’m just confused what they were doing episodes 2-4. I was shocked when my brother told me there was 6 totally episodes after ep5 last week.

I agree the last two eps were prly the best since the pilot a lot of it just didn't feel earned...as someone else mentioned Priors Dad being crooked should have been a bigger part of the overall series instead of focusing so much on the dumb s\*\*\* with his mail order bride, the cleaning ladies felt like an afterthought and then suddenly are criminal masterminds who somehow piece together that ALL the researchers were involved in Annie's death...the series overall focused too much on the mine and annoying characters like the daughter and Priors wife instead of staying on the mystery itself

Perfectly summed up my thoughts. Agree , those finale reveals felt like they were written up a week ago ..zero developments. Just boom , here it is lol

i didnt even start new season - tonight i would binge it

The cleaning lady stuff tries to justify itself as permissible because they are the invisible victims and then in dialogue as "just a story" admitting it's a wish fulfillment.

And it doesn't work because narratively, if they aren't going to be monsters that pop off at the end (John Doe, Errol William Childress), you want to spend time with them. The old lady that f\*\*\*ed Rust Cohle's dad should be one of them! It's right there! She's like barely in the show otherwise!

Why not use the TV show about their murder.... to spend time with them? No? Just cops and daughters of cops and sisters of cops? Okay 👍

I agree that the show focused on the wrong things. The Hank corruption subplot should have taken place over several episodes. Instead it’s all forced into episode 5 and feels completely unearned.

The best example I can think of is Pete’s interaction with Leah in the holding cell. There are too many scenes like that. They ultimately amount to nothing and feel like a complete waste of time. This season wanted to say a lot of things, but it spent too much time on scenes that felt superfluous.

Starting the episode, they got some balls going in those caves ngl, ain’t no way I’m going there

“Rose Agineau” is such a funny character when you zoom out on the show

I used to be the Joyce Carol Oates of my little college town, prestigious academic and all that came with it, writing my papers; one day I just had to throw it all away ya know? Move to Alaska, start f***ing this doomer of a single dad. Live the dream. Now I get my kicks burying bodies. For townspeople, the cops… okay mostly cops, I do a LOT of disposing on their behalf, not my place to be asking questions though

Every good finale has two 5 minute monologues from new characters tying up all the loose ends

Just an absolutely dud of a season

Maybe in season 5 when can meet someone who had s***with Marty's grandpa. The possibilities are endless.

How f***ing cringe, jesus f***ing christ, victim complex 101.

I have doubts that this season was even done in good faith.

I don’t think anyone was doubting. People itt been trashing it since day 1 (rightfully so)

HBO got reviewers on payroll now, huh?

No need king.

Sits bad writing. Plain and simple. That would be the over simplification but anyone who’s at least watched a few movies seen a few shows would be able to see this right away.

Felt so forced