Reply
  • Aug 15, 2022

    If there’s even a difference at all. Cus is seems arbitrary sometimes but in some cases deliberate.

    Do you personally even care about it?

  • Aug 15, 2022

    Nothing

    Just depends on how the srtist wants to word things

  • "with" sounds more classy in my opinion, idk what it is.

  • Aug 15, 2022

    Its also an older way of saying featured before "featured" was a thing too iirc

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    2 replies

    With is featuring
    Featuring is with

  • Aug 15, 2022

    with sounds more personal

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Whippey

    With is featuring
    Featuring is with

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    4 replies

    “With” means it’s a duet, implies both artists are equally contributing and it belongs to both of them, both are top billing or coheadliners

    “Featuring” means it’s the main artist’s song with an appearance from another

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    2words

    “With” means it’s a duet, implies both artists are equally contributing and it belongs to both of them, both are top billing or coheadliners

    “Featuring” means it’s the main artist’s song with an appearance from another

    This is what I always thought too.

  • yeah feature sounds like somebody just phoned something in and was really in the studio working together with the main artist on the song.

    thats just what I think of.

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    LightsOut

    This is what I always thought too.

    Party of duets that don’t have with.

    Plenty of features that aren’t listed.

    It’s a personal decision that doesn’t really distinguish one from the other.

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    6 replies
    2words

    “With” means it’s a duet, implies both artists are equally contributing and it belongs to both of them, both are top billing or coheadliners

    “Featuring” means it’s the main artist’s song with an appearance from another

    This is what inspired this thread

    These are technically ALL features lol.

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    Does it effect how artists get paid like it does in movies?

  • Aug 15, 2022
    Whippey

    Party of duets that don’t have with.

    Plenty of features that aren’t listed.

    It’s a personal decision that doesn’t really distinguish one from the other.

    Finding exceptions to the rule doesn’t mean the rule isn’t generally true

    It is not an arbitrary personal decision about wording, if anything there are business implications

  • Aug 15, 2022
    Josk2

    This is what inspired this thread

    These are technically ALL features lol.

    I’ve noticed this too. Prolly some BS to account for streaming numbers both artists

    I don’t think it’s an “artistic” choice

  • Aug 15, 2022
    babylon sherm

    Does it effect how artists get paid like it does in movies?

    Either that or artists just put in the contract that they want to be a co lead instead of a feature, it changes how it looks on streaming

  • read the contract

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    edited
    Josk2

    This is what inspired this thread

    These are technically ALL features lol.

    Some of it has to do with streaming and contracts I’m sure but what I said is the general difference in meaning

    With implies that it’s more of a joint song rather than a cameo appearance. Whether you agree with that categorization is case by case and has a business element to it but that’s what it means, and that’s why artists would rather be credited as with

    I assume “with” means you get more royalties/credit for streams than a feature too but not sure on that

  • Aug 15, 2022
    Whippey

    With is featuring
    Featuring is with

  • Aug 15, 2022
    Josk2

    This is what inspired this thread

    These are technically ALL features lol.

    Feat. Is for backing vocals in this case maybe

  • Aug 15, 2022
    Josk2

    This is what inspired this thread

    These are technically ALL features lol.

    it's only like this on spotify

    on apple music for pain 1993, it says feat.

  • Aug 15, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    “With” is a spotify thing they rarely put that on Apple music

  • Aug 15, 2022

    & and X means they are both leads

    with and feat is a feature

  • navraj

    “With” is a spotify thing they rarely put that on Apple music

    Yes i think with is the same as feat

  • Aug 15, 2022

    I think with might imply co-ownership or something