Why are all these putting the Girl so confusing remix as the Charli standout, imo, Von dutch is 1000x better and should be getting considered as SOTY

Also, Not Like Us is not even a top 25 Kendrick song let alone song of this year

I kinda agree but the remix was THE moment so I get it

It's the highlight of the album cycle as far as singles go

Oh they will never make me hate this album !

Yeah i can see it but I guess I'm forgetting that these publications have to consider that kinda stuff while trying to balance it with lesser known picks that are favorites by that publication.

Yeah, they're definitely factoring in how big of a cultural stamp some of these selections had. Same with what you said about "Not Like Us," though it's still just a really good song.

Hey now top Kendrick song in my heart

wow honestly this vid kinda expressed how i felt about this album in almost every facet perfectly

when it comes the charli comparisons, its place in the current pop zeitgeist, and the project's actual influences/references

great stuff

I love jvcki wai

Did I hallucinate p4k calling NLU mid in a track review when it dropped, or am article moaning about it?? I must be tripping.

Name what should be #1 from a cultural lens.

Looks like they didn't review Not Like Us, hilariously enough. I don't doubt what you said tho. Just a matter of having to eat their words once they see what something does over time.

to be fair, I believe Alphonse Pierre was documenting the beef overall so he may have been more harsh towards the songs being released but of course Pitchfork is not just Alphonse so

I mean, first we'd have to acknowledge that the publications being posted have varying "cultures" no? So the top pick probably wouldn't (and shouldn't) be so stationary. The variation is part of the fun of these lists.

if i had to pick a charli song for soty, it would be everything is romantic but that's just me

Yeah that was my first thought, I know people follow his writing and have picked up on biases or whatever lol. I always keep in mind though that the initial review isn't really reflective of the overall feeling. I think that's where a lot of folks get P4k f***ed up. Or they know and just don't care lol.

Youre thinking of euphoria

Alphonse reviewed it and said it was mid and moaned about it

Best Dance Album is a lock. hopefully

pitchfork.com/features/lists-and-guides/best-albums-2024/?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=dhtwitter&utm_content=app.dashhudson.com/pitchfork/library/media/478609570

pitchfork best albums list is oUT

Was just coming to post lol, I'll add in OP and transcribe later

p4k list very nice

• Pitchfork — The 50 Best Albums Of 2024 | #1. Cindy Lee - Diamond Jubilee

1. Cindy Lee - Diamond Jubilee
2. Charli xcx - BRAT
3. Jessica Pratt - Here in the Pitch
4. MJ Lenderman - Manning Fireworks
5. Nala Sinephro - Endlessness
6. Waxahatchee - Tigers Blood
7. Mount Eerie - Night Palace
8. Bladee - Cold Visions
9. Astrid Sonne - Great Doubt
10. Kim Gordon - The Collective
11. Mannequin P**** - I Got Heaven
12. skaiwater - #gigi
13. Nilüfer Yanya - My Method Actor
14. Rafael Toral - Spectral Evolution
15. Still House Plants - If I don't make it, I love u
16. DORIS - Ultimate Love Songs Collection
17. Arooj Aftab - Night Reign
18. Mk.gee - Two Star & The Dream Police
19. Magdalena Bay - Imaginal Disk
20. Mabe Fratti - Sentir Que No Sabes
21. Clairo - Charm
22. Tyla - TYLA
23. Adrianne Lenker - Bright Future
24. KA - The Thief Next to Jesus
25. Jlin - Akoma
26. Vampire Weekend - Only God Was Above Us
27. Godspeed You! Black Emperor - “NO TITLE AS OF 13 FEBRUARY 2024 28,340 DEAD”
28. Cassandra Jenkins - My Light, My Destroyer
29. xaviersobased - keep it goin xav
30. Mdou Moctar - Funeral for Justice
31. Laura Marling - Patterns in Repeat
32. Fievel Is Glauque - Rong Weicknes
33. Hurray for the Riff Raff - The Past Is Still Alive
34. Blood Incantation - Absolute Elsewhere
35. Sabrina Carpenter - Short n' Sweet
36. Kali Uchis - ORQUÍDEAS
37. Lisha G & Trini Viv - Groovy Steppin Sh*t
38. Being Dead - EELS
39. This Is Lorelei - Box For Buddy, Box For Star
40. Erika de Casier - Still
41. 坂本龍一 Ryuichi Sakamoto - Opus
42. Loidis - One Day
43. حمد Ahmed - Wood Blues
44. Milan W. - Leave Another Day
45. 454 - Casts of a Dreamer
46. Chanel Beads - Your Day Will Come
47. Helado Negro - PHASOR
48. Djrum - Meaning's Edge
49. Chief Keef - Almighty So 2
50. Wendy Eisenberg - Viewfinder

Pitchfork delivered. I knew they would lol

Another #1 for Cindy Lee. Another #2 for Charli. They're eating

Almighty So 2 on another list! F*** it I'm relistening later today lol

Absolutely disgusting list lmfao