Anime/Manga Thread 🐉 Winter 25' ❄☃

Reply
  • Oct 29, 2023
    Tranquility

    Please stop using Google translate it is garbage compared to DeepL

    Never heard of DeepL, good looks

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies

    Pluto is good so far, but aside from Shinya Ohira (who's back must hurt from bringing all the sakuga) this show has nearly zero animation, and all that blame has to go to Urusawa for likely having too much control and restricting a lot what you can actually do in this medium

    I was kind of initially blaming this issue on director Toshio Kawaguchi (he did AD the ugliest episode of Evangelion, due to Ghibli staff having no retakes, so not his fault entirely), but once again I feel like this wasn't his fault. This is pretty much a one to one adaptation and I feel like so much potential with the visuals was lost and in its place there is a lot of less than stellar cgi, and super bland compositing. You have animators like Hirofumi Matsuda on here and a ton of veterans who feel so toned down that there isn't nearly anything interesting or exciting. And it sucks that there was likely a lot more scenes that had to be changed over this time period with them likely going to Urusawa and him nixing them entirely.

    And it's not like I am begging for more action, but the characters move so boringly and it's not exactly exciting watching two characters talk with minimal body language, only having Fugita's designs carry. It sucks, considering how long the show was in production, these scenes in the trailer didn't even make it in sakugabooru.com/post/show/240796 sakugabooru.com/post/show/240797 the credit list has a lot of talented animators and it looks like they did close to nothing, or were just guiltily tagged

    Long story short, keep these heady authors away from animation if they had something more boring in mind, and they don't understand the utilization of the medium they have at their disposal

  • Oct 30, 2023

    Puella Madoka Magical Girl is cool and all

    But Madoka crying every gd episode starting to annoy tf outta me

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    5 replies

    anilist.co/user/Zaris hi sorry if my watch list looks like a first time anime watcher, cause I literally got back into it 3-4 years ago

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    edited

    reading Tranq's reviews are hilarious cause their 1/5s on my rating scale falls anywhere between a 1-6 out of 10 on my scale

    so any cryptic notes makes it harder to envision where it exactly falls

  • Oct 30, 2023
    Carmen is Composed

    https://anilist.co/user/Zaris/ hi sorry if my watch list looks like a first time anime watcher, cause I literally got back into it 3-4 years ago

    added

  • Oct 30, 2023
    Carmen is Composed

    https://anilist.co/user/Zaris/ hi sorry if my watch list looks like a first time anime watcher, cause I literally got back into it 3-4 years ago

    Followed

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Carmen is Composed

    https://anilist.co/user/Zaris/ hi sorry if my watch list looks like a first time anime watcher, cause I literally got back into it 3-4 years ago

    What made you fall off and come back a super enthusiast

  • Oct 30, 2023
    Carmen is Composed

    https://anilist.co/user/Zaris/ hi sorry if my watch list looks like a first time anime watcher, cause I literally got back into it 3-4 years ago

    followed

  • Oct 30, 2023
    Osama bin Harden

    What made you fall off and come back a super enthusiast

    having the time to watch it

  • rano 🇧🇷
    Oct 30, 2023

    Time to peep pluto

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies
    Carmen is Composed
    · edited

    Pluto is good so far, but aside from Shinya Ohira (who's back must hurt from bringing all the sakuga) this show has nearly zero animation, and all that blame has to go to Urusawa for likely having too much control and restricting a lot what you can actually do in this medium

    I was kind of initially blaming this issue on director Toshio Kawaguchi (he did AD the ugliest episode of Evangelion, due to Ghibli staff having no retakes, so not his fault entirely), but once again I feel like this wasn't his fault. This is pretty much a one to one adaptation and I feel like so much potential with the visuals was lost and in its place there is a lot of less than stellar cgi, and super bland compositing. You have animators like Hirofumi Matsuda on here and a ton of veterans who feel so toned down that there isn't nearly anything interesting or exciting. And it sucks that there was likely a lot more scenes that had to be changed over this time period with them likely going to Urusawa and him nixing them entirely.

    And it's not like I am begging for more action, but the characters move so boringly and it's not exactly exciting watching two characters talk with minimal body language, only having Fugita's designs carry. It sucks, considering how long the show was in production, these scenes in the trailer didn't even make it in https://www.sakugabooru.com/post/show/240796 https://www.sakugabooru.com/post/show/240797 the credit list has a lot of talented animators and it looks like they did close to nothing, or were just guiltily tagged

    Long story short, keep these heady authors away from animation if they had something more boring in mind, and they don't understand the utilization of the medium they have at their disposal

    more evidence that a lot of animators were not informed their scenes would be cut or modified with cgi

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    3 replies

    niggas don’t talk about dandadan enough

  • Oct 30, 2023
    Carmen is Composed

    https://anilist.co/user/Zaris/ hi sorry if my watch list looks like a first time anime watcher, cause I literally got back into it 3-4 years ago

    <100 completions caught me off guard considering how knowledgeable u are

    followed

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Faith

    niggas don’t talk about dandadan enough

    great manga man
    i thought the anime announcement would spark more interest

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    I Love Sushi

    great manga man
    i thought the anime announcement would spark more interest

    every week is peak art and story they been on a run for a minute

  • Oct 30, 2023
    Faith

    every week is peak art and story they been on a run for a minute

    fs tatsu's art is always so crisp
    seiko my beloved

  • Oct 30, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Carmen is Composed
    https://twitter.com/dkruapuopy88675/status/1717466792204046722

    more evidence that a lot of animators were not informed their scenes would be cut or modified with cgi

    Nahhhh

  • Oct 31, 2023
    Osama bin Harden

    Nahhhh

    This show could’ve been so much more, I don’t think we’ve even seen a Kawaguchi interview yet

    There is no a way a Ghibli animator like him would be this conservative

  • Oct 31, 2023
    Faith

    niggas don’t talk about dandadan enough

    it's so good. easily my favorite weekly series i read rn other than one piece

  • Oct 31, 2023

    who itt is RemiEva on anilist? meant to ask the other week when they followed me on there

  • Oct 31, 2023
    Faith

    niggas don’t talk about dandadan enough

    great manga

  • Oct 31, 2023

    though i will say, (and im not caught up) but dandadan story kinda feels like a lot is going on all at once atm

  • Oct 31, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Tranquility

    Or we can ping OJ

    "Everyone isn't scum like me, so I know you guys are speaking your real feelings from the bottom of your hearts, but after creating something I'm not satisfied with, it actually hurts, so please just leave me alone.

    I will make up for this in my future work. Until then, I'll live as the worst animator who tarnished this masterpiece."

    It's actually not that bad of an auto translation tbh, not too different from what I got from it