HNDRXX - No, but a personal classic to me

Culture - Yes

IYRTITL - Yes

The Pinkprint - Yes

TLOP - Yes

TRAPSOUL - Yes

Tha Carter IV - No

DAMN. - Yes

ASTROWORLD - Yes

What y’all got?

Agree with all your opinions except Future cuz that album a classic to me

only if you're reading this. the rest are personal classics at best but not good enough to deserve the branding of classic

IYRTITL, TLOP, DAMN for sure

Astro and Culture maybe

Culture isn’t a classic?

That’s the most unarguable one on the list to me

hndrxx, carter 4 no

iyrtitl, tlop, trapsoul yes

rest are on their way to classic status but i dunno if id give it yet

musical quality? absolutely not.

i’ve been meaning to ask this site what makes Tha Carter IV not a classic for a hot minute

only argument i see against it is the lack of influence and it being a little bloated

some yeah

No one listens to any of those MID albums

DAMN, probably. The rest are almost there.

And then there's Astroworld.

A lot of people don't think it's very good, which is not great if you insist on calling something a classic instead of just a successful album

Its rep has definitely improved in light of worse projects he's put out since though

DAMN
TLOP
Culture 1
IYRTITL

Yes, the rest no

It’s the worst Carter by a landslide

???

It’s a great album

Culture is a classic for so many reasons man

that belongs to C5

not the pinkprint but the other ones are

Everything but The Pinkprint is classic or classic-adjacent

Seems like a bait thread I only think hndrxx isn't a classic but it's good

Only zoomers won't admit c4 is a classic tbh

Damn you don't like deep introspective Wayne? One of my favs from him tbh

The only album on here thats not a certified classic is Hndrxx but i guess you can still argue its a classic. Great album though

the handful of introspective tracks don’t save that album from it’s dated production, nonsensical sequencing, throwaway tier tracks and embarrassing features

Ban