Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    2 replies
    yungboiezi

    I get pop stars have a room full of writers for their songs

    But if your a rapper and you have 10+ writers writing your songs then at that point you have no talent.

    cardi b is a pop star

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Oblivion X

    Ehh not really

    I mean look at who the site is named after

    Kanye came in as a producer and didn’t start his rapping career until he got signed.

  • Aug 12, 2023

    I’d write sumn so fire for cardi bro

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Dotenheimer

    cardi b is a pop star

    Talk to anyone in the industry who has been in it for like 20 years and pry them on the subject, they’ll be sure to make you think far less about your favorite artists in this respect

    Edit; wasn’t meant to reply to you bro mb

  • Aug 12, 2023

    Yung cardi yung cardi yung cardi a diva 🗣️

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply

    If she has this many writers, where's the music at

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Dotenheimer

    cardi b is a pop star

    She’s a rapper that went pop, her main talent is rapping which is debatable because she probably doesn’t write a single lyric in her songs lol

  • Aug 12, 2023
    Donebefore

    Talk to anyone in the industry who has been in it for like 20 years and pry them on the subject, they’ll be sure to make you think far less about your favorite artists in this respect

    Edit; wasn’t meant to reply to you bro mb

    I can literally just ask people that I know in the industry. lol

  • Aug 12, 2023

    i got a writing camp in every state is a bar tbh

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    2 replies

    i don’t mind people having writers but there’s no reason for you to have this many writers bro. you damn near an AI artist at this point with no original thoughts

  • Aug 12, 2023
    Noir

    If she has this many writers, where's the music at

    Pardi was preoccupied f***ing megan for the past 3 years so cardi's album was on hold

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    yungboiezi

    She’s a rapper that went pop, her main talent is rapping which is debatable because she probably doesn’t write a single lyric in her songs lol

    her main talent has never been rapping. its making popular songs....

  • Aug 12, 2023

    she out here movin like Dr Dre

  • Niggamortis 👨‍🚀
    Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply

    Wasn't one of her writers that Pardi guy who dated Meg?

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    2 replies
    yungboiezi

    Kanye came in as a producer and didn’t start his rapping career until he got signed.

    Yeah that's my point. He's still talented despite having writer camps.

    And if we just talking rapping, he's still a talented rapper

  • Aug 12, 2023
    splice

    i don’t mind people having writers but there’s no reason for you to have this many writers bro. you damn near an AI artist at this point with no original thoughts

    we’re too far gone people in here rushing to defend it “so what” it away and not even a&rs lol

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Niggamortis

    Wasn't one of her writers that Pardi guy who dated Meg?

    yeah he wrote all of her hits on her debut album

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Dotenheimer

    her main talent has never been rapping. its making popular songs....

    By that logic Beyoncé’s main talent is making popular songs and not singing & choreography.

    And Cardi is not doing the production or writing the songs so what exactly is she “making” ?

  • Aug 12, 2023
    splice

    i don’t mind people having writers but there’s no reason for you to have this many writers bro. you damn near an AI artist at this point with no original thoughts

    It's not like all 10 people are writing the song line by line. It's 10 people writing for the song, and the artist picks the best one or just maybe half of one and half of another

  • Aug 12, 2023
    Niggamortis

    allan poes in different area codes

    Bars

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    2 replies
    Oblivion X

    Yeah that's my point. He's still talented despite having writer camps.

    And if we just talking rapping, he's still a talented rapper

    as a Nigga who desperately wants more 04-07 dropout bear esque s*** to listen to nobody Kanye works with sounds like that when they don’t work with him

    They’re good rappers but Kanye is the common denominator for why those first three albums are the only thing to sound like that lol

  • Aug 12, 2023

    J Cole has writing camps or did you guys forget

  • Aug 12, 2023

    only barbs care about this

  • Niggamortis 👨‍🚀
    Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    NightsLikeThis

    yeah he wrote all of her hits on her debut album

    I thought it was just a few tracks damn.

  • Aug 12, 2023
    ·
    2 replies
    Oblivion X

    Yeah that's my point. He's still talented despite having writer camps.

    And if we just talking rapping, he's still a talented rapper

    He’s a producer, so he’s held at a different standard than a rapper that started as one from the ground up.

    It’s the same reason why the Chronic is considered a classic even though Dre probably didn’t write any of it.

Thread was locked by
a moderator