Reply
  • Apr 7, 2022

    then you should understand that the biggest dangers to a society are not those that are symptoms of it's contradictions but its catalysts

  • Apr 7, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Womanpuncher69

    George Bush

    Literal leader of the GOP

  • Apr 7, 2022
    internet buddy

    Literal leader of the GOP

    my bad thought it was about Trump even then i still don’t find it important to differentiate between democrats and GOP in most meaningful discussions like this one , it wasnt GOP that toppled Libya after all

  • Apr 7, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Scratchin Mamba

    What is then?

    Like political parties specifically political organization too broad

    Unsure but I don't think the question is too valuable. Whatever nation the most dangerous party is in will be the one carrying out the parties desires so we should look at the issue by nation not party

    Also the GOP/Dem difference is nearly immaterial for international policy as @krishna_bound said the same people pay them both, so if GOP is mentioned, the Dems should be too. GOP does wreak havoc with their domestic policies though

  • Apr 7, 2022
    Yuzzy

    Unsure but I don't think the question is too valuable. Whatever nation the most dangerous party is in will be the one carrying out the parties desires so we should look at the issue by nation not party

    Also the GOP/Dem difference is nearly immaterial for international policy as @krishna_bound said the same people pay them both, so if GOP is mentioned, the Dems should be too. GOP does wreak havoc with their domestic policies though

    I'd say the GOP is definitely worse on climate change, even if ithat difference is the biggest in rhetoric, dems aren't great either tho

    I agree the question isn't that important tho, but it's not as ridiculous as people are making it out to be imo

  • Apr 7, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    Chomsky's on auto-pilot. The man's at the age where old folks just spew bullshit because they got nothing better to do

  • Apr 7, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    the most dangerous organization in all of modern history is the los angeles lakers, mashallah they missed the playoffs

  • Apr 7, 2022
    gabapentin

    the most dangerous organization in all of modern history is the los angeles lakers, mashallah they missed the playoffs

    Nobody wants to watch these Lakers in the playoffs anyway.

  • Apr 7, 2022
    ASAKI

    Chomsky's on auto-pilot. The man's at the age where old folks just spew bullshit because they got nothing better to do

    Been on auto-pilot the last 20 years

  • Apr 7, 2022
    SCOUSER

    Disagree with that. There is such a significant difference in their social policies that it's unhelpful not to make a distinction at a time when Republicans are coming for abortion rights and the LGBT community.

    It doesn't make the Dems less trash than they are but you have to make the distinction. You can't tell someone they are voting for the same evil if they're voting against the party that's tryna make it a crime to be Trans or have an abortion.

    i meant billionaires and politicians

  • Apr 7, 2022
    eye contact

    Political systems have always been determined and upheld by the economic systems underlying them

    yessir

  • Apr 7, 2022
    ·
    3 replies
    eye contact

    Political systems have always been determined and upheld by the economic systems underlying them

    gramsci and other marxist theories on culture have expanded on this much better than the older stuff

    the base does not directly uphold the superstructure but rather it is intertwined like a ouroboros

  • Apr 7, 2022
    sniper

    gramsci and other marxist theories on culture have expanded on this much better than the older stuff

    the base does not directly uphold the superstructure but rather it is intertwined like a ouroboros

    yea but there's a distinction between the two for a reason

  • Apr 7, 2022
    sniper

    gramsci and other marxist theories on culture have expanded on this much better than the older stuff

    the base does not directly uphold the superstructure but rather it is intertwined like a ouroboros

    Obviously, but political systems are meant to manage modes of production. They must uphold each other but the mode of production provides the foundational basis for society

  • Apr 8, 2022
    sniper

    gramsci and other marxist theories on culture have expanded on this much better than the older stuff

    the base does not directly uphold the superstructure but rather it is intertwined like a ouroboros

    the base does not directly uphold the superstructure but rather it is intertwined like a ouroboros

    Gramsci has made great theoretical contributions, but they did not go against earlier theories. That's the view Marx and Engels themselves outlined, it was never said that the superstructure is some epiphenominal product of the base with no function of its own. Gramsci just elaborated on it and went more in depth. It's one of the most common b******izations of Marxist theory along with that historical materialism is some type of "stages theory"

  • Apr 10, 2022
    ·
    2 replies

    I am ready for this collectivist authoritarianism you speak of

  • Apr 10, 2022
    Cudderwalks

    I am ready for this collectivist authoritarianism you speak of

    A socialist body with a strong central body

  • Apr 11, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Cudderwalks

    I am ready for this collectivist authoritarianism you speak of

    You'll be left with what Shanghai is now

  • Apr 11, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Yuzzy

    You'll be left with what Shanghai is now

    Better than here

  • Apr 11, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    eye contact

    Better than here

    Under what measure?

  • Apr 11, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Yuzzy

    Under what measure?

    Life expectancy, education, productivity to earning ratios, access to medical care, access to infrastructure, violent crime rates, etc

  • Apr 11, 2022
    ·
    2 replies
    eye contact

    Life expectancy, education, productivity to earning ratios, access to medical care, access to infrastructure, violent crime rates, etc

    Idk where you mean by here, but I'll take lesser statistics if I can be assured the state won't imprison or starve me

  • Apr 11, 2022
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    Yuzzy

    Idk where you mean by here, but I'll take lesser statistics if I can be assured the state won't imprison or starve me

    The US has an incarceration rate 4 times higher than China. Also China’s been making so much more progress in solving existent food insecurity than the US

    wfp.org/countries/china

    npr.org/2020/09/27/912486921/food-insecurity-in-the-u-s-by-the-numbers

  • Apr 11, 2022

    Once again there is absolutely no consideration amongst western “leftists” like @Yuzzy as to what conditions lead to this illusory “freedom” in the US and exactly what consequences the third world has had to experience in order for the US to secure this fake form of freedom.

    It’s just liberalism with a social program veneer

  • Apr 11, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Yuzzy

    Idk where you mean by here, but I'll take lesser statistics if I can be assured the state won't imprison or starve me

    You know I don't consider China socialist but they've made more progress on food insecurity and living conditions in general than pretty much any other country in the past 40 years and they have an incarceration rate several times lower than the US and only slightly higher than Canada, so these aren't exactly great points to criticize them on lol