The genre took off when rappers were more clean cut, started using melody and making records that could cross over
It was already becoming Billboard ready when Drake showed up. It's the first time rap has declined and who are the artists running it? Who brought afro and latin pop into rap? Who treats rap like a side hustle? Who is more focused on their demographics than their rap discography?
You’re trolling
He’s selling out arenas 10x over and making 5 million a show
The genre is not declining because of him but rather, because rap has gone away from his archetype
Kanye was taking it there, the. Drake / Cole / Kendrick / Sean took it there too.
Rap really started declining when they pushed guys like lil baby and lil durk to the forefront (guys I love)
Y’all blaming individuals when you should be blaming the institutions behind these individuals
Because the content and image doesn’t glorify ignorance and labels/fans prefer to listen to and promote music that they can’t relate to, so they can seem more hip and in the know.
The same reason why y’all dress the way you do
If the music was good we would be listening and there would be demand
But it’s not, it’s watered down, we come full circle
I just told you why
It’s the lack of monoculture
If you can’t create new stars, the genre will eventually suffer
There’s soooo many ways to digest music today, that everyone is in their own bubble and as a result, can’t come together to choose a new artist to champion. Labels can’t condition the public to pick new stars because everyone is listening to their own playlists and what not
The fact that all the popping rappers of today are from the trenches are in and out of jail and have opps does not help to be fair. they have 0 crossover appeal but even if they did, it’d be harder
Those other genres still have a monoculture
rap can’t create new stars partially because of what you mentioned and also the lack of a desire to subvert the current homogeneous sound and trends, and create something new/push hip hop forward
we don’t have anyone in the mainstream doing anything particularly interesting nor new as you said, and they’re essentially regurgitating the same sound across albums over and over again lol
1000s of artists like this exist already bro. Not sure what the disconnect is
The disconnect is the casual fan wants convenience, opening up apple/spotify to listen to "you're" music as they go thru every other artist they like to listen to daily.
Drake stopped being that a long time ago and has lowkey took massive influence from the artists we’re referring to though BECAUSE it brings him numbers. However I’m sure he can actually shift that if he wants to but there’s a reason why he hasn’t (honestly nevermind backlash)
I don’t disagree
But the public still doesn’t see him that way and thats what matters
He’s definitely an opp rapper from Atlanta now but the public still sees him at large as Marvin’s room drake
What your image is is just as important as the actual music
I just told you why
It’s the lack of monoculture
If you can’t create new stars, the genre will eventually suffer
There’s soooo many ways to digest music today, that everyone is in their own bubble and as a result, can’t come together to choose a new artist to champion. Labels can’t condition the public to pick new stars because everyone is listening to their own playlists and what not
The fact that all the popping rappers of today are from the trenches are in and out of jail and have opps does not help to be fair. they have 0 crossover appeal but even if they did, it’d be harder
Those other genres still have a monoculture
I don't necessarily disagree but this theory is framed in a way that is self defeating
There's a steep decline in the prevalence of monoculture in America but it's still there and this trend can be turned around (although extremely difficult due to the way social media algo's are built and will require serious craftiness)
Ice spice is an example of someone breaking through recently
You’re trolling
He’s selling out arenas 10x over and making 5 million a show
The genre is not declining because of him but rather, because rap has gone away from his archetype
Kanye was taking it there, the. Drake / Cole / Kendrick / Sean took it there too.
Rap really started declining when they pushed guys like lil baby and lil durk to the forefront (guys I love)
Drake single handedly revived Durk's career. Wants and Needs is one of Baby's biggest songs. He had his hands on the levers for a decade. Don't play innocent now
The guy would rather do EDM and play basketball than make another IYRTITL
The disconnect is the casual fan wants convenience, opening up apple/spotify to listen to "you're" music as they go thru every other artist they like to listen to daily.
Well that's why I replied to dude that said it's the perfect time for a shift to take place. Yes Spotify and Apple are centralized but that's what contributed to the position we're in now. So a shift would have to take place to decentralize and put artists back in power
I don’t disagree
But the public still doesn’t see him that way and thats what matters
He’s definitely an opp rapper from Atlanta now but the public still sees him at large as Marvin’s room drake
What your image is is just as important as the actual music
Idk about that bro. You got mfs that love ATL rap that love Drake and thank he’s the GOAT. 10 years ago they wouldn’t be caught dead being a fan of his. If he was still seen as the Marvin’s Room guy today, those guys wouldn’t be fans of his. Props to him for converting those people though. But.. with great power comes great responsibility to move the game forward
Drake single handedly revived Durk's career. Wants and Needs is one of Baby's biggest songs. He had his hands on the levers for a decade. Don't play innocent now
The guy would rather do EDM and play basketball than make another IYRTITL
Do you think Drake decided to get with Durk and Baby or his management did
rap can’t create new stars partially because of what you mentioned and also the lack of a desire to subvert the current homogeneous sound and trends, and create something new/push hip hop forward
we don’t have anyone in the mainstream doing anything particularly interesting nor new as you said, and they’re essentially regurgitating the same sound across albums over and over again lol
This is where we’ll kind of disagree
I think that even if new acts pop up that are interesting, it still wouldn’t get rap out of the place that it is now
There’s too much toothpaste out of the tube. In America, across all forms of entertainment, they are having huge issues creating new stars
I think…if you’re trying to figure out how to create an act that can sell 500K first week and sell out arenas…if the answer simply is make better music then you’re losing the plot. There’s a larger more serious issue at hand
If the music was good we would be listening and there would be demand
But it’s not, it’s watered down, we come full circle
This is an age old side speak white ppl use to under value black music.
The music that doesn’t sell is actually good. It’s not marketed in a way that benefits whiteness
Noname had the best album last week and it won’t sell well.
If she was selling her p**** she would be selling better though.
Do you think Drake decided to get with Durk and Baby or his management did
Drake’s management has no control over any creative decisions he makes anymore
Well that's why I replied to dude that said it's the perfect time for a shift to take place. Yes Spotify and Apple are centralized but that's what contributed to the position we're in now. So a shift would have to take place to decentralize and put artists back in power
That shift you're speaking of have nothing to do with the app that people are consuming music on, that shift will have to take place with the label who are backing the artists that make the same music in different packaging.
Y’all blaming individuals when you should be blaming the institutions behind these individuals
Drake’s management has no control over any creative decisions he makes anymore
Idk I tend to think people in artist ears make actions happen. Drake and Bobbi an example both under the same agency
Anyone feel free to correct me if I am wrong
Drake single handedly revived Durk's career. Wants and Needs is one of Baby's biggest songs. He had his hands on the levers for a decade. Don't play innocent now
The guy would rather do EDM and play basketball than make another IYRTITL
Well he did not single handedly revive durk’s career huh?
And yes wants and needs is one of baby’s biggest records but so?
To say Drake has hurt the genre is just not true. It’s very clear that his archetype was what was working
Its like Joe said, this is HipHops 50th anniversary and labels aren't even celebrating it after they milked it for every last cent, doesn't surprise me they ready to move on to Afrobeat and Reggaton/other latin genres
Lil Baby killed hip hop. he was supposed to carry the genre on his back after Drake but he dropped the ball
(i never liked him, but that was how he was positioned)
Well he did not single handedly revive durk’s career huh?
And yes wants and needs is one of baby’s biggest records but so?
To say Drake has hurt the genre is just not true. It’s very clear that his archetype was what was working
How if it’s bigging up mid ass artists? lmfao the last artist that was great he gave a co-sign to is 21 Savage. The rest of the people he does this with are mid let’s be honest
Idk about that bro. You got mfs that love ATL rap that love Drake and thank he’s the GOAT. 10 years ago they wouldn’t be caught dead being a fan of his. If he was still seen as the Marvin’s Room guy today, those guys wouldn’t be fans of his. Props to him for converting those people though. But.. with great power comes great responsibility to move the game forward
Yeah but the niggas that love atl rap are a small small faction
He’s very good at playing both sides. Thats why he put out honestly nevermind
when you go to a drake show, there’s a reason why over half of his set list is 10 to 11 years old
A large majority of his base still see him as the Over / find your love / hold on we’re going home guy.
This is an age old side speak white ppl use to under value black music.
The music that doesn’t sell is actually good. It’s not marketed in a way that benefits whiteness
Noname had the best album last week and it won’t sell well.
If she was selling her p**** she would be selling better though.
under value black music? huh
I’m just tryna say mfs want to sound like baby, future, gunna and not cordae, mick Jenkins, and noname
and that’s ok
I wish it was more of a complete picture but it’s not these days
That shift you're speaking of have nothing to do with the app that people are consuming music on, that shift will have to take place with the label who are backing the artists that make the same music in different packaging.
Yes it does. The streaming apps in place now are notorious for their low payouts and siding more with the industry at large/major labels more than the artists. I don't see that changing unless artists were to shift to a different model somewhere else like Bandcamp