those of you defending it like this arent even on the first 40 pages of the thread . I was willing to give the s*** a chance even when Greg Berlanti was involved

Woah woah lets all be nice

Requirements to defend the show:

You must post before condomeyes says

when this show in concept with lindelof is exactly what I asked for .

About to get my haircut can’t wait

brother You said I wanted to hate the show. You lied.

I proved your LIE was wrong.

Nobody is perfect

A haircut will always make you feel like a new man. It provides strength, confidence and determination to kick ass.

I’m not perfect bro damn

Horrible movie

This show is GOOD

Hal Jordan dying STINKS

The TD finale and how the mystery wrapped up was the most hated and critisized thing about that show at the time. So in a way lanterns is a pretty good copy

I am not saying someone cant love the show. I am glad people love the show . Even if I dont personally love the writing of the show. To lie and place it like I didnt want a show when i been more hyped than many on here. Is goofy

you were more hyped for Supergirl than this . You liked this I am glad you liked this. You liked supergirl I am glad you liked it. None of that is going to disallow me to say ways I was disappointed in the writing of this show. Even when my expectations changed based on seeing the show.

Watchmen for me was better than this show and got infinitely less viewers. This show for me is still better than everything else in the DCU. The character isnt ruined and I think its a slippery slope if they revive Hal.

You lied when you said I was in the thread all week. When I forgot it was finale til yesterday. You keep lying because thats how you discuss. You lie and personally attack the person. Rather than discuss the show yourself and what you liked about it. If you loved every last story decision in this episode and this show that is excellent I do not care.

Yeah there was not enough shown about the characters in this show where it being revealed anyone killed Hal would be that crazy besides John or really himself. if Hal killed himself obviously it wouldnt go over well but would be the only true twist that could live up to showing it so early in the show. Would be hated by fans. I cant really think of a character where it would be better per se to kill him. I just think the execution of the kill wasnt that good. Felt like a parody to some degree . Even if yes I understand she feared for her child.

The reason I don’t like discussing with you is because you also love forgetting s***. Right after it ended I said what I did and didn’t like. You also add random s*** in that people never say. It gets old and I get tired of typing paragraphs on things I never said (you don’t always do this but sometimes you do) I’ve discussed plenty of things. You just get annoying and calling you a c*** isn’t a personal insult. I say it to my friends.

“You don’t discuss it you just insult me”

“If you enjoyed or didn’t enjoy the show I DONT CARE”

“Why don’t you discuss?”

i mean yea i agree with this. there's no way kerry was going to end up in jail after all the development and relationship building they did between her and john and hal.

I never said you didnt say it at all. You get upset that others of us are discussing a show and view it as solely hate or to troll you . When I am discussing a show entirely separate from you. Me discussing the show or piece of art isnt to troll you. Its to discuss art on a forum. ITS NOT CENTERED ON YOU. You did this same s*** when I was discussing the mechanics of wolverine and winded up being right.

You become hostile and text me on discord about s*** on here. If you watched or discussed something I enjoyed and s*** on it I am not messaging you stop talking about that or taking it personally we have different taste. As long as you dont insult me i do not care.

Seems to be hitting with critics

I dont think Jail was the solution either . I just feel like the whole plot line was in a way rushed for me so didnt land as hard as I wish it did.

Okay

Sure