American gangster is undeniable

444 has received recent ktt hate but is also a classic rap album shout out no id

I know how you feel about jay z tho lol

Well, extremely debatable, but you're entitled to your opinion.

Do you genuinely thing AG or 444 are some of the top 50 hiphop albums ever made though?

You should ban yourself

Lool, I'll just chalk it up to personal preference

you’re an Eminem stan in 2026 lmfao hang it up

How many classics Eminem have?

What's the Difference
Forgot About Dre
Bad Guys Always Die
Guilty Conscience

Eminem better than Jay Z

there’s a big difference

i haven’t forgotten

so do good guys

mine is clean

this is a completely respectable opinion if you died in 2001

I’d put AG there yes. So 4 top 50 rap albums ever.

And wtt still is an achievement in so many ways.

I mean, your top 50 is your top 50 I guess

I reckon so

Whole lotta outkast Kanye jay tribe wu mob deep ect

There's actually never been a year when Jay Z was better, now I think on it.

But I completely sympathize with whatever hearing issue you have that makes you think otherwise

Try Vince Staples new s***... I dont think you'll enjoy it but should help shake up your old ears a bit

2013 easily, and that was Jay’s worst album vs. Em’s worst album at the time (he has since surpassed this)

2017 by a landslide as well

2020 if we wanna count A Written Testimony, though most of the songs were older

4:44 vs Revival

it’s not even close

New rule: every jay z album that’s not ostensibly bad is a classic

might have to straight up ban op if he tries floundering about Revival being better than 4:44 (joking)

this has been a rule for like 20 years wym

He won’t because his rage bait doesn’t work when you talking specifics

Its only dumb broad statements

Nah, MMLP2 had higher highs... unfortunately lower lows as well.

Bad Guy is probably the best song Eminem has ever written.

I've never listened to Revival in it's entirety so I'll give you that

I'm actually starting to figure out that you never really GOT why Eminem was so great in the first place.

Go check out the lyrics to Renegade and actually compare the scale of what both artists are talking about.

Not trying to diminish Jay Z and the urban struggle but on one hand you have a street level tale, and on the other you have federal censorship, religious insights, social commentary that's still relevant to today

I’m just making sure everyone else knows

Some people have good comprehension skills