Colouring book deserves all its flowers but yeah how they ranked the top albums over the past decade had no rhyme or reason

Fair point. I know plenty of folks my age who have hit their breaking point with him as well. One of my buddies from college who used to defend him to the death completely gave up on him after the MAGA s***. On the one hand I get it, but on the other this is what and who you signed up for.

I didnt even say that tho, i said right after that it would've been considered great no matter what but to deny the critics had an impact, the fact is they gave it another level of legitimacy that whether u like it or not impacts the way ppl percieve the album even to this day

its why mfs who dont even know rap will go on about how great this album is even though his first 3 are just as good if not better

Why do they matter so much man its a damn publication with random writers you don't know the names of. They just music fans too but get paid and have agendas

Who cares brah. I get it when the scores really high or a 10 because they spent years carving their attention off the fact they barely give certain scores but yall realize yall getting mad at a freelance journalist rn right? Like not even a staff writer

Y’all didn’t have a problem with pitchfork until now

This is beside the point but I feel like we're almost ready to acknowledge that the Fantasy Trilogy (808s-Yeezus) is just as influential and imo as good as the Dropout Trilogy (CD-Grad)

10 years since Yeezus is going to f*** me up emotionally, but that's when I feel like people are going to start to see how f***ing perfect those three albums are

Chance should send this to Ye for screaming at him

!

Yeah but a 9.1 higher than Blonde 2 points below TPAB was ridiculous and they clearly were going w the hype of Chance seeming like the next big guy then completely abandoned it

I’m tired

Nigga pitchfork has been getting trashed on here for years niggas went at a writer on KTT1 on his page

Why are y'all pretending that Kanye and his fans haven't hated P4K since TLOP?

Sorry, but we're only listening to black critics on this one

a lotta users been acting brand new in general since this dropped

You’re certainly not posting TochiRTA unironically?

Kanye really got them in shambles like I really think people are just mad he was successful.

This feels like resentment cause he dared to still be big after getting cancelled

Reviews are important, they just have gone out the window when discussing Kanye..since the Trump stuff. To the media he's basically Manson, R. Kelly without any real scandal. He's not going to get great reviews again all around, ever imo.

📠

But be so quick to post MBDTF’s score

Camp deserved that rating tbh

Tochi has interesting opinions on hip-hop
Can't say the same for Pitchfork

The scores only exist to make you read their writeups.

Stop falling for this advanced clickbait u nerds.

This honestly cannot be life lol

Both too high.

He’s entertaining I’ll say that