Yeah and I havnt seen the movie yet so obviously I can’t judge it yet.

More so just giving my pre-thoughts because I am going into it with a lens that is very willing to critique.

also took him to mean that maybe it was best Scorsese stuck to his style because the story from the perspective of the Osage should be told by an Osage

feel like Marty would've really had to walk a fine line portraying the Reign of Terror from the pov of the Osage without getting the trauma p*** label

understand the critique about how depicting a loving relationship and guilty conscience minimizes the evilness of it all but I read Scorsese said the Burkhart family told him there was a lot of love between them and wanted him to portray it that way

I think they're all fair critiques and the conversation of how and who tells the story is important. at the same time, the Reign of Terror is finally going to become part of the national conversation thanks to this film, which is quite an accomplishment itself

Between this and Oppenheimer they both raise the question of being sure we aren't clapping for the wrong reasons

Ooooh
This has been tripping me up for awhile

His critique is honestly super fair / understandable and he laid it out in the best way

What was he putting in the insulin? I think I caught a glimpse of the label and thought it said morphine. But I didn’t think that would kill you in small doses over time. Idk.

Maybe it wasn’t actually killing her but just sedating her like they said. Idk. I probably read the label wrong

Poison. The morphine was to slow her down

absolutely

Robert de Nero is really one them ones

Another blassic from the goat

Not a single second that shouldn’t have been there

Nice

I liked The Irishman more but that’s top 5 Scorsese to me

Lickers of the Sour Poon

Masterpiece. Another one in the books. Scorsese emulates John Ford and von Stroheim.

This is much better than Irishman

that said, I think I liked Silence better

one takeaway from this movie if I had to pick one: love doesn't cure stupidity

Silence is top 5 Scorsese, I think it might be the most “mature” film he’s ever made

wow, just wow. goat did it again. that was f***ing amazing

This was one of the darkest movies i think ive seen in a long time