ye over LR?

zoomer detected

best since Yeezus, tied with Pablo imo

Some of the lists I’ve seen on her is worrying.

How can an album which includes Can’t tell me nothing, flashing lights and everything I am be bottom of a list?

Still better than TLOP
Ye
Jik

Need to live with it for another 3 years though

Instant classic. No bad songs

I rank it Somewhere in the middle.

why? Cause Yeezus being at the bottom?

Best since Yeezus

Donda & KSG the only Kanye albums I've genuinely enjoyed as a whole since Yeezus

LR
MBDTF
YEEZUS
808S
TCD
KSG
GRAD
WTT
DONDA
CS
TLOP
YE
JIK

It’s an okay album. It def seems like Kanye is actually tying more to make a good album but it still feels like 80% of the songs are unfinished. A lot of songs feel like demos that hardcore Kanye fans would love but should never be officially released

If the album was cut down to under 15 and then fleshed out those, this album would have been something.

Overall, a step in the right direction but still a feeling disappointment as a Kanye fan

His 3rd worst

yeah

Just curious what in particular you think sounds so unfinished? A lot of times (but not all the time) what people think of as unfinished seems like part of the style he was going for. So I'm curious which parts sound unfinished to you and if I'd agree.

album works really well until Jonah, which derails it quite a bit. Then it gets muddy here but it gets back on track with Believe What I say. However, Junya doesn't fit at all imo as well but from 24 onwards it straddles between solid and great. Probably his best since MBDTF for me.

His best s*** since yeezus

About 3 maybe 4 tracks too long from being a masterpiece. Bro this album feels like a volcano in your mind when you’re in your bag something about it is very intense even when most of the songs are relatively mellow

It kind of has this uneasy feeling, as if someone’s emotions are completely bottled up and they’re ready to explode, but as they’re surfing through each track they find a way to resolve those emotions...until the next track, then repeat.

Righttttt , teetering on the brink of a very bitter destruction until it’s like “wait I got god and he’s got me” . The tracks that indulge in Sin and human imperfection are such a nice touch too

the only track I feel is unfinished is kmsa , Royce's voice in ye's verse is incredibly annoying to me

I feel this albums biggest problem is sequencing all the rest is perfect

compared to his first 6 i wasn’t impressed

but im pleasantly surprised bc of his output over the past few yrs. he was genuinely terrible at one point but this showed he can still make something alright

I’m 26. Y’all really pressed bout me thinking LR and Grad are near the bottom I’ve felt that way since 2010 at least. LR just has the most songs that I personally skip on a Kanye album and graduation is too clean and polished pop sounding for my tastes

bottom 5 album, it's 6-7 rn cause idk yet if i like JIK or Donda more

7.5/10