feel like anyone who disagrees is clearly just being subjective

I know objectivity is hard sometimes, but I don't make the rules

Idk, but it's one of my favorites ever

yes, it's the best game ever made

Not even close. Matter of fact no gta game is even top 3 rockstar.

Also lol at "objectively"

minecraft

No, 4 is

Outside of GTA, Fallout NV or Halo 3

Red Dead Redemption 2 is

Feel like with all the longevity and noise about 5, 4 gets overlooked a bit but it's a really great game

Minecraft

No, but it is one of the most technically impressive achievements for its time. Also ive probably played gtasa more than any game this year.

FIFA 12

One of the best for sure and probably the most impressive game for its time

super smash bros melee

Its up there. But then again, I feel like all GTA's are

Yes

Well, saints row 2 is better so I’d say that’s a stronger candidate

One of them

But Diablo 2, specifically Lord of Destruction expac is the greatest game of all time

Ninja gaiden 2 on Xbox 360 better