Reply
  • Jul 31, 2023

    You gotta be a certain kind of individual for pitchfork to rate your album honestly

  • Jul 31, 2023

    At least 5.7 is above mid

  • Jul 31, 2023

    where is ryan dombal

  • Jul 31, 2023
    medschooldropout24

    Not a surprise when Pitchfork also gives this guy a platform

    https://twitter.com/Evanryt/status/1685038500419162112

    Good tweet

  • Jul 31, 2023
    medschooldropout24

    Not a surprise when Pitchfork also gives this guy a platform

    https://twitter.com/Evanryt/status/1685038500419162112

    I know we laughing at the vocabulary but all jokes aside

    This white man spittin lol

  • Jul 31, 2023
    KFA

    Mhmm should I give it a 7.7 or an 7.8?
    F*** it let's do a 7.8

    Not good enough for an 8, so lets do a 7.8.

    decimals are cause multiple staff gives their score n they average it out (it's what they used to do. might all for bait now who knows)

  • Jul 31, 2023

    Honestly I haven't even thought about Putchfork in a long time

    But this just shows how out of touch and possibly agenda driven they are

    Without reading im guessing the review contains references to the Astro world festivsl and Kanye West. Am I right

  • Jul 31, 2023
    medschooldropout24

    Not a surprise when Pitchfork also gives this guy a platform

    https://twitter.com/Evanryt/status/1685038500419162112

    He’s not wrong

    Travis Scott has never been described more accurately and I like his music lol

  • medschooldropout24

    Not a surprise when Pitchfork also gives this guy a platform

    https://twitter.com/Evanryt/status/1685038500419162112

    Where's the lie lol

  • Jul 31, 2023
    codeine cowboy

    guarantee the score would’ve been higher if the tragedy didn’t happen

    not really he hates trav

  • Jul 31, 2023

    Pitchfork is so out of touch

  • Jul 31, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Love Life Utopia

    I could see it. Most people I played it for only like about 6 songs which is about a 3/10. Personally a low 9 for me, but I’m a big fan so biased

    Most people listen to songs anyway rarely full albums.

  • Jul 31, 2023
    aLIEN

    stop making p4k threads, you're part of the problem

  • Jul 31, 2023

    Is this album not about a 6/10? Seems right to me

  • Jul 31, 2023
    ·
    edited

    I will turn Alphonse Pierre to an outline and mail the photo of it to his grandma along with a free t shirt

  • Jul 31, 2023
    ·
    1 reply

    Not even mad at the score but wow this is poorly written
    What the f*** is this sentence? “Many of the genre’s great albums of the year are so completely absorbed in regional movements that they are even cutting through the noise (see: Sexyy Red’s Hood Hottest Princess and Veeze’s Ganger).”

  • Jul 31, 2023
    llama

    considering whats in the review, u would expect lower than a 5.7

    Iirc the whole office rates the album and the average of their scores is what gets published

  • Jul 31, 2023

    Pitchfork and Rolling Stone been trash and even if the latter loves this album they're still trash

  • Jul 31, 2023
    mannigra

    Not even mad at the score but wow this is poorly written
    What the f*** is this sentence? “Many of the genre’s great albums of the year are so completely absorbed in regional movements that they are even cutting through the noise (see: Sexyy Red’s Hood Hottest Princess and Veeze’s Ganger).”

    Pitchfork is an absolutely abortive, pathetic excuse for a critical outlet

    This Nine Inch Nails review is the biggest hunk of s*** "criticism" ever published

    pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/5798-things-falling-apart

  • Jul 31, 2023
    ·
    edited
    ·
    3 replies

    Why do yall always feel the need to go after the writers of these reviews when they give it a score you don't like? The album is still going to be best selling rap album of the year and no one is forcing you to change your own opinion of it.

  • Jul 31, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Dragonpiece
    · edited

    Why do yall always feel the need to go after the writers of these reviews when they give it a score you don't like? The album is still going to be best selling rap album of the year and no one is forcing you to change your own opinion of it.

    Because their reviews blow and they're a culture vulture outlet

    pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/5798-things-falling-apart

    miserable review

  • Jul 31, 2023

    Even when P4K gives good score their s*** is still ass

    Rolling Stone the only outlet that's worse

  • Jul 31, 2023
    Dragonpiece
    · edited

    Why do yall always feel the need to go after the writers of these reviews when they give it a score you don't like? The album is still going to be best selling rap album of the year and no one is forcing you to change your own opinion of it.

    dudes who only listen to the rap equivalent of marvel movies mad when it doesn't get 10/10 scores alongside commercial ubiquity

  • Jul 31, 2023

    yeezus but 10 years later and nowhere near as good. seems like a fair score to me

1
...
7
8
9
...
38