Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Cow

    Because they were never invested in a capitalist system. That's the point.

    The best communist is one with nothing to lose. Once the state can take something from you, you become weak.

    Why risk a comfortable life?

    So people who don't have an interest in keeping capitalism in place (not privileged whites) are usually the ones who advocate overthrowing it.

    Yeah that is the point lol

  • Mar 8, 2021
    allmygirlsdoyoga

    Didn’t read OP, but the right is literally filled with privileged whites who tell you that they’re revolutionaries.

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    6 replies

    white leftists are the most racist subset of people in America tbh

    very frequently they view minorities or people who are "less privileged" as inherently inferior to them either consciously or subconsciously, or believe that these people are in need of them to be saviors

    personally I am a slightly right-leaning 21 yr old but I was never thrilled about trump as an individual or ideologically honestly, but I couldn't bring myself to vote for Biden due to this philosophy that I just described being a consistent in the things his campaign did and said. There is an automatic assumption that non-white individuals are in need of white people to help them because we aren't smart enough or competent enough to have personal responsibility

  • allmygirlsdoyoga

    Didn’t read OP, but the right is literally filled with privileged whites who tell you that they’re revolutionaries.

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Cow

    Fam, can you tell me why it is dumb because I want to know.

    man I went to go take a shower calm down lol
    my first problem is this huge straw man of anarchist of all they do is burn s***, that are against everything. I dont think anarchist well depending on the tendency are against organisation, theres groups like food not bombs, which help working class people. Also that proletariats are just brainless creatures that are brainwashed by these upper class anarchist, when the proletariat aren't dumb themselves they can be anarchist themselves. idk whats up with the Spain part, every groups have symbols, and people can be class traitors for example Engels and Kroptken were class trainers against the rich, like how cops are class traitors against the working class. Also anarchism has a rich tradition of theory like Bakunin and Emma Goldman.

  • OP
    Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    3 replies
    Scratchin Mamba

    So people who don't have an interest in keeping capitalism in place (not privileged whites) are usually the ones who advocate overthrowing it.

    Yeah that is the point lol

    Indeed. That is the point lmao.

    So when I see privileged whites playing the communist, I wonder what the f*** they are doing. I know they don't want it. They have everything to lose and nothing to gain. Most of these communists online are middle class whites who have done well within the system.

    Like your mans Synopsis.

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    jg33

    white leftists are the most racist subset of people in America tbh

    very frequently they view minorities or people who are "less privileged" as inherently inferior to them either consciously or subconsciously, or believe that these people are in need of them to be saviors

    personally I am a slightly right-leaning 21 yr old but I was never thrilled about trump as an individual or ideologically honestly, but I couldn't bring myself to vote for Biden due to this philosophy that I just described being a consistent in the things his campaign did and said. There is an automatic assumption that non-white individuals are in need of white people to help them because we aren't smart enough or competent enough to have personal responsibility

    i don't necessarily disagree w what you're saying, but im lmao at people that "subconsciously" see people as inferior. that's one of those things that sounds nice but doesn't making any sense

  • Mar 8, 2021

    Cow more like C***

  • Mar 8, 2021
    Cow

    Indeed. That is the point lmao.

    So when I see privileged whites playing the communist, I wonder what the f*** they are doing. I know they don't want it. They have everything to lose and nothing to gain. Most of these communists online are middle class whites who have done well within the system.

    Like your mans Synopsis.

    I think the post would be better if it was talking about just online leftism in general, then I would agree 100%

  • Mar 8, 2021
    allmygirlsdoyoga

    Didn’t read OP, but the right is literally filled with privileged whites who tell you that they’re revolutionaries.

  • OP
    Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Womanpuncher69

    man I went to go take a shower calm down lol
    my first problem is this huge straw man of anarchist of all they do is burn s***, that are against everything. I dont think anarchist well depending on the tendency are against organisation, theres groups like food not bombs, which help working class people. Also that proletariats are just brainless creatures that are brainwashed by these upper class anarchist, when the proletariat aren't dumb themselves they can be anarchist themselves. idk whats up with the Spain part, every groups have symbols, and people can be class traitors for example Engels and Kroptken were class trainers against the rich, like how cops are class traitors against the working class. Also anarchism has a rich tradition of theory like Bakunin and Emma Goldman.

    You're right, I am talking a subset of anarchists. It is hard to really gauge anything within anarchism because it is so full of s***e. But this thread is specifically to do with more militant people. I state that in the thread. The more militant of anarchists are actually contradicting their ideology by forcing their own ideology on people.

    The proletariat and lumpenproletariat are very easily influenced by the intelligentsia. There is a reason why when you check out a riot, it is mostly young, often vulnerable people. They are people who are easily led and who have nothing to lose. You will never see a riot in the west with a group of middle class white people.

  • Mar 8, 2021
    Mango

    Try again

    most regular people i talk to who aren't caught up in some like right wing bullshit love bernie sanders, and people who have lived elsewhere before coming to the US are like "why the f*** didn't you elect this guy instead" lol

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    2 replies

    op has a point y’all especially about idealogy

    but the people op should be mad about is bourgeoisie leftists

    last paragraph lowkey hittin

    watch this docu series @op

    i think it will help you better articulate your point.

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    jg33

    white leftists are the most racist subset of people in America tbh

    very frequently they view minorities or people who are "less privileged" as inherently inferior to them either consciously or subconsciously, or believe that these people are in need of them to be saviors

    personally I am a slightly right-leaning 21 yr old but I was never thrilled about trump as an individual or ideologically honestly, but I couldn't bring myself to vote for Biden due to this philosophy that I just described being a consistent in the things his campaign did and said. There is an automatic assumption that non-white individuals are in need of white people to help them because we aren't smart enough or competent enough to have personal responsibility

    You dont know what a leftist is. Because biden ain't one of em

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Teki

    i don't necessarily disagree w what you're saying, but im lmao at people that "subconsciously" see people as inferior. that's one of those things that sounds nice but doesn't making any sense

    I say that because I don't think their heart is in the wrong place most of the time -- most genuinely support left wing ideas, in this instance out of seeing a need for racial equity, etc. Society has almost brainwashed some people into this.

    That's different to me than someone who wakes up hating minorities on some KKK s***

  • OP
    Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    black hedi slimane

    op has a point y’all especially about idealogy

    but the people op should be mad about is bourgeoisie leftists

    last paragraph lowkey hittin

    watch this docu series @op

    !https://youtu.be/MHFrhIAj0ME

    i think it will help you better articulate your point.

    Thanks for this. I appreciate you helping me understand it more and apply it to my arguments and thoughts. I will watch.

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    ktt2.com/why-is-that-idiot-synopsis-on-here-10257

    OP stay keeping comrades name in ya mouth.

    I don't eat meat but I'll make an exception when I turn u to some beef

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    rnb sponge

    https://ktt2.com/why-is-that-idiot-synopsis-on-here-10257

    OP stay keeping comrades name in ya mouth.

    I don't eat meat but I'll make an exception when I turn u to some beef

    Lol moment I saw who op was I knew this was another fantasy post of his where he assumes to know s*** about me

  • Mar 8, 2021

    but, @OP to be fair I'll read ur posts and give an honest response to what u actually typed

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Cow

    Thanks for this. I appreciate you helping me understand it more and apply it to my arguments and thoughts. I will watch.

    yes, i don’t agree with a lot of the s*** you say, but i can tell you’re operating in good faith

    it’s easy to just paint the left as these privileged whites, and there is a real element to this

    however you need a more nuanced perspective. this should be a good start, but it also takes a lot of reading from both leftists and criticism from those on the right

    good luck dude

  • Mar 8, 2021
    jg33

    I say that because I don't think their heart is in the wrong place most of the time -- most genuinely support left wing ideas, in this instance out of seeing a need for racial equity, etc. Society has almost brainwashed some people into this.

    That's different to me than someone who wakes up hating minorities on some KKK s***

    i mostly agree w that

  • Mar 8, 2021
    Synopsis

    Lol moment I saw who op was I knew this was another fantasy post of his where he assumes to know s*** about me

    mfs stay making up random s*** about you cause they think they boutta get 5 likes and get that dopamine hit with the notifications

  • Gojira 🦖
    Mar 8, 2021

  • Mar 8, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Cow

    You're right, I am talking a subset of anarchists. It is hard to really gauge anything within anarchism because it is so full of s***e. But this thread is specifically to do with more militant people. I state that in the thread. The more militant of anarchists are actually contradicting their ideology by forcing their own ideology on people.

    The proletariat and lumpenproletariat are very easily influenced by the intelligentsia. There is a reason why when you check out a riot, it is mostly young, often vulnerable people. They are people who are easily led and who have nothing to lose. You will never see a riot in the west with a group of middle class white people.

    the forcing ideology part seems like its from Engels On Authority, its been a few years since I was an anarchist I still have I guess sympathies for them but here's their defence against if u care enough to read it theanarchistlibrary.org/library/the-anarchist-faq-editorial-collective-an-anarchist-faq-09-17#toc40

    Its around the halfway point of the faq, we did see a riot in the west with middle class white people though it was the capitol riot, a "middle class revolution" isn't ever gonna be a leftist revolution, from my experience in leftist organisation near me most of the people tend to be working class themselves, or minorities, or transgender people.

  • OP
    Mar 8, 2021
    black hedi slimane

    yes, i don’t agree with a lot of the s*** you say, but i can tell you’re operating in good faith

    it’s easy to just paint the left as these privileged whites, and there is a real element to this

    however you need a more nuanced perspective. this should be a good start, but it also takes a lot of reading from both leftists and criticism from those on the right

    good luck dude

    Indeed. The title of this thread was originally mentioning social media. As with most people, most of my political debates happen online. My perception of the left is heavily influenced by my time speaking to individuals online. I can't speak to such a wide variety of people from all different cultures anywhere but online.

    To be clear, I am on the far left myself. I have chilled in more recent times to understand more viable approaches. There was a time when I would not vote for somebody in the centre. I see the benefit in it now. Socialism is a viable option right now, but the free market has to exist in some form. That should be the current aim.

Thread was locked by
a moderator