What defines an objectively bad album
Nothing to me. What is bad to someone could be enjoyable to another and I’m not going to act like their or my opinion matters more it’s all on the individual
well the Kendrick one is right
Jay has The Carters at least
Ye has Ye, JIK, Donda 2
Drake has Scorpion and CLB at least
Encore was always a bad album
Encore and Relapse the Eminem albums I go back to the most
Encore and Relapse the Eminem albums I go back to the most
Relapse is fire
Relapse is fire
Yeah Relapse is definitely not one of Eminem’s bad albums
Yeah Relapse is definitely not one of Eminem’s bad albums
Top 4 right after his classic 3 imo
We need to stop equating imperfect/flawed albums with bad albums they are not the same thing
Kanye has two horrendous albums
Drake has three ass albums (Scorpion Side B, CLB, NVM)
Kingdom Come isn't very good but has some classic songs
We need to stop equating imperfect/flawed albums with bad albums they are not the same thing
If i listen to it and I don't like what i'm hearing I consider it bad
The term Classic is irrelevant in this conversation (it’s pretty much obsolete anyway) but yeah:
Kanye (obviously)
JAY-Z
Kendrick Lamar
Drake
Ye
Kingdom Come
Thank Me Later
Kendrick has no bad albums
If i listen to it and I don't like what i'm hearing I consider it bad
This is why nobody can agree on anything anymore
Anyone can personally “not like” anything upon hearing it depending on their personal biases and how they feel that day, how attentive they feel like being at the moment, what they are listening on etc. Making a snap judgement based on feelings as fleeting as that isn’t really my thing. I can separate music that doesn’t grab me from music that’s actually poorly made. Big difference.
I prefer to be objective and ask my self questions like is this well produced? Is this a good performance? Was this executed well? Usually when I actually stop and think instead of just blindly throwing my biases around I find that professional artist are doing good work more often than not and I just need to have more patience as a listener.
it is annoying when people try to force a “weak” album instead of just being honest and going full d***rider but kanye does have weak albums
ye, ksg, jik
ksg?
in my honest opinion the only one that doesn’t have a bad album in the OP is Kendrick. Morale may be boring to some of y’all (a specific group on here) but it’s by no means a bad record. I cannot say the same for JIK, , Donda 2, Scorpion, CLB, MCHG, Best of Both Worlds, Blueprint 2, etc.
Y’all really out here counting Donda 2??
Anyway Ye has 2 mid albums
Drake has probably 2-3 mid albums
Jay has 3
Kendrick has 0
Y’all really out here counting Donda 2??
Anyway Ye has 2 mid albums
Drake has probably 2-3 mid albums
Jay has 3
Kendrick has 0
Nah Donda 2 don’t count if it did it would disqualify Ye but it was never officially released on all platforms so it’s a demo imo
A significant percentage of the songs are poorly executed, have bad verses or production, or are unlistenable
For example having 2-3 misses on a 16 track album is not a bad album
Having 7-8 misses on a 16 track album is a bad album
"Having 7-8 misses on a 16 track album is a bad album"
You are literally describing scorpion