Honestly feel that Gen IV was when Pokemon was at its peak.

It's when all 4 regions felt interconnected at the time.

The past is the past

The games BW , competitive mons ORAS/SM

interesting.

feel like BW was the best story

gen iv was comp peak

Old gens prob ADV it's the best by far with the most balanced meta , DPP it's like playing HO vs HO 90% of the time

yeah...cant disagree with that

Peakemon

back when u were in u mom womb

Emerald was the absolute peak imo. Could be nostalgia though.

feel everyone's favorite game was the one they started with???

Fire Red

Nah I started with Kanto/LeafGreen

My fav is Sinnoh/Pearl

could sinnoh be properly remade?

underground would be AMAZING

HeartGold & SoulSilver is its peak

In terms of what?

The peak was the beginning. When people were actually collecting cards and a Holo Charizard was every kids grail

Pokémon Yellow on GBA... that era

Red

No I started with Red/Blue. Emerald was just the peak in terms of quality and popularity.

The games keep evolving, but as far as the designs of the actual Pokémon, they started becoming way less memorable after 4th generation.

Literally you could show me a slideshow of every Pokémon in order and I’d be able to name every one up to the Diamond/Pearl ones. Even a decent amount of the Black/White ones. X/Y and forward is where it gets blurry even tho there are some standouts. I literally had to Google the Sun and Moon starters yesterday cause I legitimately couldn’t mentally place them for a second.

gen 7

Crystal

Good times bro

I started with Emerald but my favorite is Platinum

why firered?

for me, its purely nostalgia for cant only

My first was Yellow but Emerald was the first one I properly played

Me in Yellow was just a lil kid f***in around

I think this is key right here.

There's only so much Pokemon you can design before you get redundant or just absurd.

Do you think we can ever get a game like Platinum again?

Platinum was on a whole other level compared to past games.

WiFi + the use of dual screens were very transformative