Reply
  • Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    edited
    Oblivion X

    Should of just kept it at country and folk songs, the country hip hop/dance fusions didnt land well

    This except for riverdance

  • Oct 2, 2025
    goretex

    The song with Miley Cyrus is just a different level of music tbh

    Actual peak

  • Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    edited

    IMO if it was sequenced something like this and just these songs this would be renaissance level aka masterpiece

  • Gosh 😹
    Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    My wife loves it, but shes texan and a beyonce stan, wasn't for me tho, but I'm excited for Act 3

  • Oct 2, 2025
    Botney

    album sounded like homework on US history

    Damn near the entire album is jsut emotional and personal and stories

  • Oct 2, 2025

    I forgot tyrant is on this lol wtf

  • Oct 2, 2025

    It's a classic in her discography
    You guys are still gonna be listening to it in ten years

  • Oct 2, 2025

    the music just wasn’t good enough to justify her taking up the rifle for the sake of a genocidal empire.

    Whole thing was super manufactured and jarring, even to those without political consciousness

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Gosh

    My wife loves it, but shes texan and a beyonce stan, wasn't for me tho, but I'm excited for Act 3

    did u go to the concert

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Oct 2, 2025

    i felt way different about the album post concert

  • Gosh 😹
    Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    goretex

    did u go to the concert

    Yeah, it was amazing as expected. I'm just not a country nigga at all so the themes didnt hit for me

  • Oct 2, 2025
    deleteduser579

    The album is decent. A little bloated and scattershot in some places but I think it's generally a good project

    Definitely not fully country Bey, a full tape of DADDY LESSONS/16 CARRIAGES/ALLIGATOR TEARS/LEVI'S JEANS, (yeah I know) tier songs would've been real nice

    This guy gets it

  • Oct 2, 2025
    aLIEN

    bro, I'm not going to explain to you the concepts of ambiguity and ironized symbolism, she literally buries the idea of traditional american ideals in the very first song... how old are you, 12?

    Her Buffalo soldier merch dont really help your case crodie

  • Oct 2, 2025

    it’s amazing music that won’t get appreciated until we look at her career in retrospect

  • Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    goretex

    And it f***ing got AOTY what the f*** do you mean where did it go wrong you niggas really lack so much self awareness bro

    Waitamin waitamin waitamin waitamin waitamin waitamin

    You spent the last few months arguing over how insert artist here artistry supersedes insert artist here artistry because he stopped caring about awards like Grammies because they was just industry/white validation.

    Now you saying cowboy carter is valid BECAUSE it won a grammy?

    Which one is it goretex? Is it oochie wally or one mic?

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    2 replies
    Gosh

    Yeah, it was amazing as expected. I'm just not a country nigga at all so the themes didnt hit for me

    yea i feel that fr i dressed up with my girl and wore cowboy boots and a cowboy hat (nanamica waterproof)

    and dis sweater

    i went mad trim brah then the concert started and i was like yoooooo wait we did make da american flag

    wait this IS OUR COUNTRY

    nah fr though i feel like the concert was as instrumental to an albums context as yeezus. i still aint rocking with the entire project the way i did renaissance but i deef started to understand more. happy yall had a good time beyonce is always fun with the misses

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    2 replies
    insertcoolnamehere

    Waitamin waitamin waitamin waitamin waitamin waitamin

    You spent the last few months arguing over how insert artist here artistry supersedes insert artist here artistry because he stopped caring about awards like Grammies because they was just industry/white validation.

    Now you saying cowboy carter is valid BECAUSE it won a grammy?

    Which one is it goretex? Is it oochie wally or one mic?

    bro.... you know what i mean. its on paper more successful than renaissance we just aint like the s*** as much

  • Oct 2, 2025
    goretex

    yea i feel that fr i dressed up with my girl and wore cowboy boots and a cowboy hat (nanamica waterproof)

    and dis sweater

    i went mad trim brah then the concert started and i was like yoooooo wait we did make da american flag

    wait this IS OUR COUNTRY

    nah fr though i feel like the concert was as instrumental to an albums context as yeezus. i still aint rocking with the entire project the way i did renaissance but i deef started to understand more. happy yall had a good time beyonce is always fun with the misses

    Betsy ross was black?

  • Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    goretex

    bro.... you know what i mean. its on paper more successful than renaissance we just aint like the s*** as much

    Basketball terms: Are we rating it by stats or by the eye test?

    If I still cared about the grammies I could make a very compelling another album coulda won aoty that year (but i havent watched a grammy show since like ‘13 i think.)

  • Gosh 😹
    Oct 2, 2025
    goretex

    yea i feel that fr i dressed up with my girl and wore cowboy boots and a cowboy hat (nanamica waterproof)

    and dis sweater

    i went mad trim brah then the concert started and i was like yoooooo wait we did make da american flag

    wait this IS OUR COUNTRY

    nah fr though i feel like the concert was as instrumental to an albums context as yeezus. i still aint rocking with the entire project the way i did renaissance but i deef started to understand more. happy yall had a good time beyonce is always fun with the misses

    Fire fit and I genuinely f*** with what Bey was trying to say with this era

    It's like our thing at this point, it started with me surprising her with tickets to the One the Run tour with Hov, and we just been going to every Beyonce concert since

    I honestly dont trust anyone's opinion on music in general if they've never seen Beyonce in person

  • Gosh 😹
    Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    goretex

    bro.... you know what i mean. its on paper more successful than renaissance we just aint like the s*** as much

    You better keep it consistent when Kendrick wins for GNX

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    insertcoolnamehere

    Basketball terms: Are we rating it by stats or by the eye test?

    If I still cared about the grammies I could make a very compelling another album coulda won aoty that year (but i havent watched a grammy show since like ‘13 i think.)

    It’s like bro you said where did she go wrong when the only thing that’s wrong is that you ain’t like da album I’m literally just saying like outside of your opinion the album had insane cultural impact was critically acclaimed had the best tour of the year and won AOTY. The only thing that went wrong is you didn’t like it. Let’s rephrase things buddy

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Oct 2, 2025
    Gosh

    You better keep it consistent when Kendrick wins for GNX

  • HBDUSA 🇺🇸
    Oct 2, 2025

    I was never giving it a chance soon as I heard it was country

  • Oct 2, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    goretex

    It’s like bro you said where did she go wrong when the only thing that’s wrong is that you ain’t like da album I’m literally just saying like outside of your opinion the album had insane cultural impact was critically acclaimed had the best tour of the year and won AOTY. The only thing that went wrong is you didn’t like it. Let’s rephrase things buddy

    Cultural impact is debatable dawg gotta have staying power to have cultural impact