Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Apr 13, 2020
    HFM

    Overrated
    Just a good dancer, there’s millions of those

    MJ was also a fantastic vocalist tho

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Bmezy

    I wouldn’t rate her a better performer than MJ either, but who else possess the ability to sing at her level and then physically perform just as well w/her stage presence.. She ain MJ, but you gotta give credit that she’s q beast when she gets on stage

    bruno mars

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    2 replies

    I swear some of y'all forgot how important Janet was before the media and the whole JT situation f***ed up her career

    And I'm not that big of Janet fan

  • blase 🦋
    Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Bmezy

    i don’t know why ppl bringing up sales because the praise, reverence and acclaim that Beyonce receives has never came from her commercial success (records sold, singles, charts), but always stemmed from the merit of her talents as a singer and performer along with her work ethic and consistency/longevity along with her cultural influence. Britney outsold Beyonce’s discog in her debut album, yet she was never put on the same pedestal as Beyonce.. why? Because Beyonce’s stardom was never about her sales. The fact that no one performed the way she did on stage was enough🤷🏾‍♂️

    That's not true. I've been seeing this conversation brought up for a long time, since the 2000s. Her sells have been brought up in the conversation. They may not be being brought up now because she's not selling as well but they were in the 2000s. People used to have convos about who is closer to MJ, beypnce or britney and of course sells and star power were brought up.

  • Apr 13, 2020

    Beyoncé is only that big in America, there are much bigger American acts in Europe and Asia, she prob ain’t even top 10 in that regard let alone MJ status

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    rwina sawayama

    all u have to do is look at thriller's sales and realize no one is close to that

    beyonce isnt evne in the same ballpark as mj

    Adele and Ed are actually very close when you consider the global sales for their last two commercial releases.

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    John Stamos

    Adele and Ed are actually very close when you consider the global sales for their last two commercial releases.

    show me the numbers

  • Apr 13, 2020
    KingOfPop

    Imagine pairing Beyonce to this and claiming she's on the same level lmao

    !https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hxgo-Qu-ZZE&t=3184s

    Lmao this guy was standing still for 5 minutes and people out there fainting. He really GOAT

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    MrKiD

    The only person who was close to MJ is Usher, you could say JT too, but Beyonce is just closest thing imo to a Janet.

    This the most disrespectful post ever, as a MJ and an Usher fan my g.

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    MrKiD

    I swear some of y'all forgot how important Janet was before the media and the whole JT situation f***ed up her career

    And I'm not that big of Janet fan

    Janet is the only person who I have ever thought could compare/compete with Mj tbh.

    Rhythm nation era she might of had the slight edge as a dancer too.

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    rwina sawayama

    bruno mars

    Bruno has better technical dancing skill.. (same could be said about Normani/Tinashe), but he isn’t half the vocalist she is and his dancing doesn’t supplant the charisma/stage presence she has. If you notice Beyonce’s actual ‘moves’ aren’t complex, but it’s a combination of her execution, her energy and charisma that makes whatever she’s doing more captivating to watch. add on top of that that she’s effortlessly belting these impossible notes on command.. s*** hots different. I didn’t notice this until i went to the FWT with my lil cousins (who stan her).

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    rwina sawayama

    show me the numbers

    I was wrong about Ed although his numbers are getting there. Adele sold 22 million copies of 25 and 30 million of 21.

  • Apr 13, 2020
    Delejayn

    She isn’t bigger or will ever be bigger than MJ. She won’t ever be greater but I honestly don’t even think it’s that close performance wise. I think she is a way better performer. I also think her being a black women is a reason why she doesn’t sell a single much as Adele, etc. Beyoncé has been in the game for 21 years and hasn’t lost a step. She is doing stadiums after 21 years. No other artist can claim that right now. Adele, Bruno, Taylor are all In their prime. Beyoncé has two primes and she can still dominate this decade. Her longevitiy is what garners the comparisons.

    She will be in this 30 years and that’s kinda unprecedented being at the top.

    If we’re being honest, just looking at Beychella, Bey’s live performances are far more difficult and physically demanding than MJ’s. MJ’s Magic was in his dancing being effective as hell for eyecandy, but actually not requiring that much energy to execute which is perfect for a performer. Leg kick, crotch grab, shimmy, moonwalk, spin into toestand etc are way less demanding than what Bey be doing while belting out stronger vocals.

  • Apr 13, 2020
    RX Nigerian Pastor

    Janet is the only person who I have ever thought could compare/compete with Mj tbh.

    Rhythm nation era she might of had the slight edge as a dancer too.

    Word, watching Janet's videos remind me alot of MJ, so she studied him a lot but yet again she was around him all the time.

  • Apr 13, 2020
    The Retiring Mane

    You telling a woman she needs to be slapped is crazy my g.

    I didn’t know she was a woman

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    John Stamos

    I was wrong about Ed although his numbers are getting there. Adele sold 22 million copies of 25 and 30 million of 21.

    so she sold around half as much as thriller

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Sunny Sun

    Michael Jackson literally dominated his peers and all his rivals effortlessly in terms of commercial success

    Beyoncé isn’t even bigger than Adele, Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran or even Drake

  • Apr 13, 2020

    drake is this generations mj not b

  • Apr 13, 2020
    rwina sawayama

    so she sold around half as much as thriller

    Think about how long thriller has been out, also Ed is already at 22 million for divide and it's still selling well. These are albums that aren't going anywhere.

  • Apr 13, 2020

    MJ & it’s definitely not comparable

    Beyoncé is good at putting on entire shows: choreographed performances with lots of background dancers & props...which is cool for the moment

    but MJ will light up a stadium by himself, you won’t pay attention to anyone else but him

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    Flosh

    The Eagles outsold thriller

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    blase

    That's not true. I've been seeing this conversation brought up for a long time, since the 2000s. Her sells have been brought up in the conversation. They may not be being brought up now because she's not selling as well but they were in the 2000s. People used to have convos about who is closer to MJ, beypnce or britney and of course sells and star power were brought up.

    Nah.. looking at the numbers, Beyonce has NEVER been the top seller in any year that she’s been active.. not in the early 00s when she was competing with Usher, Brit, Christina A, Eminem, 50 cent, not in the late 00s when she competed with Rihanna, Katy, Gaga.. not early 10s with Adele, Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran, Drake etc.. they’ve all outsold her, yet the one constant that ppl always associated with her compared to all these ppl was that she was the goat entertainer and generally seen as more talented/ambitious. The way that all the ppl I named speaks of her like she’s a Goddess despite them outselling her is a testament of the pedestal that she’s placed on.. it never was about commercial power with Beyonce.

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    John Stamos

    The Eagles outsold thriller

    Provably false

  • Apr 13, 2020
    ·
    1 reply

    if they’re still talking about B in 30 years she can be compared to MJ

    til then hush the comparison

  • Apr 13, 2020
    MrKiD

    I swear some of y'all forgot how important Janet was before the media and the whole JT situation f***ed up her career

    And I'm not that big of Janet fan

    This can not be stressed enough, f*** CBS.

1
...
5
6
7
Thread was locked by
a moderator