I listened and it sucks

Eminem is only unanimous top 5 to whites

I agree, prime eminem washing half the industry, regardless of his skin colour

No, I'm saying your opinion is your opinion, but the opinions of the collective holds more weight especially when added to the other .ore objective criteria for measuring greatness

I'm not White, but whatever helps you sleep at night man

Ur ears suck :(

this bitter eminem stan been ranting about s*** since like 2014 ffs bro get a hobby

People actually think that? For whayt? For whayyyyyytttt?

OP is a fan of Tom MacDonald

I'll bite, who would you say is objectively the greatest artist of all time?

If it's objectively true, because art can be objective apparently, you'll have no problem saying who you think

One of the greatest versatile and talented white artists in rap? he absolutely is and that’s objective. When people say this nobody is saying he raps better than Eminem, but he can do more around the board. He produces, he sings, he plays instruments, he raps very well. That is why people consider Mac a GOAT it’s not limited
to him being white. Mac is just period hella talented compared to most regardless of race

Read through the thread, then rephrase your obviously loaded question.

Nobody said art was objective.

Read through the thread, then rephrase your obviously loaded question.

Nobody said art was objective.

I have, greatness is objective and based on a consensus of public opinion, so who is it?

He was an amazing artist, no debate, but not all amazing artists are GOATs.

BTW Eminem also did most of those things but that's another topic entirely

big daddy kane and rakim have called Em one of the goat. what's your point

That’s not even what that historical phrase means lol

Of course Eminem has been granted a lot of privileges off of being white, but that doesn’t mean that there isn’t this other section of people who have a vendetta against him because he’s white. In fact, a lot of it comes from self-hating white people themselves.

MJ
Elvis
Prince
Madonna
Beyonce
Whitney
Tupac

Close your eyes and pick at random

Except he already has been compared to them

By Hip Hop legends themselves. Nas, Jay, Ice Cube Rakim, Daddy Kane, Kendrick Drake etc etc etc. have all placed him somewhere in their top 10-5 spots or said he’s one of the greats

You can’t rewrite history

And here's where I'll prove my point; nobody would bat an eye at that list but if I were to add

SZA

Or

Lorde

Both talented artists, of course we'd all agree that they dont match up... but somehow niggas REFUSE to apply that bit of obvious logic to this conversation

Ok? And Jay z compared lil Uzi to prince. No black person that grew up in a black neighborhood grew up hearing Eminem’s music. So how is he comparable to the names you listed when the core base of hh never rocked w him like that?

Hip hops core base is vanilla white... look at KTT or go to a Jay Z concert

No it’s not.