Jul 12, 2025I ain’t paying attention to anyone called Alphonse TBH
Jul 12, 2025·1 replyPeople gotta stop caring about P4K man lol
Jul 12, 2025·1 reply
zeniramaWhenever I see a tweet like this I never see any reasoning or explanation given as to why a sexyy red album is inherently worse than a clipse album and cannot possibly be rated higher for any reason (or whichever artists are being compared)
Sexyy red hate is EXTREMELY, extremely weird, especially with the amount of rappers running around ‘living their life on tape’ and having all these fans that s*** on sexyy red in the same breath
- Jul 12, 2025·edited
Corporate MórNo it’s both
It’s a***ysis and interpretation, grounded in historical and cultural contextTo understand Coltrane you need to understand his progression from hard bop, modal jazz, etc. That isn’t an opinion it’s music history. Ignoring this context, and what shaped the sound we now call Coltrane is poor criticism
Good criticism blends objective musical knowledge (form, lineage, social context) with subjective response. It’s journalism with an interpretive lens, not just a reaction
I haven’t read this review
To understand Coltrane you need to understand his progression from hard bop, modal jazz, etc.
No you don’t, thats literally whitewashing and intellectualization and even f***ing Miles Davis was speaking out entirely against it. FIVE people liked this?
Jul 12, 2025He and all the other pitchfork dweebs will never be stopped if yall keep making threads about them and giving them the attention they want.
- Jul 12, 2025
Bet that burger ass nigga is laughing at this thread as we speak saying "yup I did it again"
- Jul 12, 2025
‘Jazz isn’t about what’s being played it’s about what’s not being played’ whoosh flew right over some of y’all heads
Jul 12, 2025I mean I disagree and think he's a bit goofy but in the age of homogeneous music criticism where everything is a 8 (cucktano aside) it's cool that pitchfork are still providing the shambles from time to time
Jul 12, 2025
Oblivion XIm surprised people still dont know that pitchfork scores are an average from multiple people's scores and not the actual reviewer
Jul 12, 2025Idk I don't think we should be this angry over somebody's opinion lol
- Jul 12, 2025
Alphone pierrr is an attention seeking hack yes but he’s not the one making the scores and he just hates pharell
Jul 12, 2025Oblivion XIm surprised people still dont know that pitchfork scores are an average from multiple people's scores and not the actual reviewer
he still picked a score around there and still wrote the snarky review
- Jul 12, 2025Corporate Mór
No it’s both
It’s a***ysis and interpretation, grounded in historical and cultural contextTo understand Coltrane you need to understand his progression from hard bop, modal jazz, etc. That isn’t an opinion it’s music history. Ignoring this context, and what shaped the sound we now call Coltrane is poor criticism
Good criticism blends objective musical knowledge (form, lineage, social context) with subjective response. It’s journalism with an interpretive lens, not just a reaction
I haven’t read this review
Inb4 they completely ignore this just to say hurt durr opinions
Jul 12, 2025Why keep posting about it and giving it more attention.
- Jul 12, 2025Corporate Mór
No it’s both
It’s a***ysis and interpretation, grounded in historical and cultural contextTo understand Coltrane you need to understand his progression from hard bop, modal jazz, etc. That isn’t an opinion it’s music history. Ignoring this context, and what shaped the sound we now call Coltrane is poor criticism
Good criticism blends objective musical knowledge (form, lineage, social context) with subjective response. It’s journalism with an interpretive lens, not just a reaction
I haven’t read this review
Well no one doing rap music reviews does this.
Jul 12, 2025We are still getting mad at a strangers opinion in the year of our lord 2025
- Jul 12, 2025Oblivion X
Im surprised people still dont know that pitchfork scores are an average from multiple people's scores and not the actual reviewer
Yeah, but his actual reviews are also terrible. He hates every mainstream male rapper.
Jul 12, 2025·1 replyI've stopped taking pitchfork seriously a long time ago. How is literally everything either a 6 or 7?
Jul 12, 2025awww did he not give ur favowite rapper a 10.0 🥺🥺
Jul 12, 2025·1 replyYou’re a massive insecure p**** if you get legitimately upset at reviews
Jul 12, 2025
SaturdayHe eats Subway like me!
https://twitter.com/Southside_Gunn/status/1943565141699641769why he look so sad
- Jul 12, 2025Salaryman
You’re a massive insecure p**** if you get legitimately upset at reviews
Jul 12, 2025His playlist stuff is always filled with “oh you don’t know about this” type s***. We know those people in real life. they’re annoying lol. But I think that’s how his brain is wired. But not a surprising review and who cares. He’s alright for certain things.
Jul 12, 2025·1 replyi think reviewing an album within days of it coming out is kinda silly but the clipse album was definitely some mid outside of a few very high highs