why do you make threads like this?

End of Transmission

Insane that this is even a question

Yes because most of them sing in church but make 🎶 outside of church.

Is OP a threadician?

"most forms of music" especially in this day and age

Acapella is still music

F*** a musician. F*** a rockstar.

Rappers took over the world.

You have a problem?

I wouldn’t say so unless they also play an instrument and possess the ability to create a song or are in a group where they contribute to that being done with the help of other instrument musicians.

What music is being made if it’s just a singer by themselves? What music is being made if it’s just a rapper by themselves?

somebody like cordae no. but somebody like smino or gunna yes

You have a problem?

Ben Shapiro type thread

Lol more like someone like Gunna No someone like Kanye West or Andre 3000 yes

IDK who that is.

Yes

Hell Tisa Korean is a musician. If you make the backing music then you are a musician

If you just do the vocals you’re a vocalist

Then the singers in the church choir are musicians.

This is wrong
You can train an understanding of music in and of itself but not athleticism.

With that being said rappers are technically musicians albeit like most singers they usually have very limited music knowledge

Any body who makes music is a musician or who is musically talented tryna do mental gymnastics is like tryna diminish their creativity
If a singer is a musician same applies to rappers

The term “musician” encompasses songwriters as well. Rappers (and some, not all singers) are songwriters, as well as vocalists. Therefore, they’re musicians.

It’s not just people who play instruments

That was a poor example because choirs can do albums with no music

But essentially vocalist vs. being able to make a full recording

Op Almost got me thinking thread got some racismo undertone lol

You think I'm a racist. Nah I'm actually African American. Parents from Nigeria and Jamaica so........

every time @op makes a thread, i feel like i’m suffering from a stroke

That’s why I said “almost”

And knew you just a goofie with that question lol