Reply
  • Mar 24, 2021
    The Young Blizzard

    How could a progressive be a Republican?

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    CLB Fractions

    you have to vote blue or republicans will win every time. if you want progressive candidates then you need to vote in primary.

    if primary turnout was same as election turnout bernie mightve won

    If Bernie became president we would have a 49-50 congress and the governor of Vermont is a Republican who would have appointed a Republican so the gop would have 1 more vote in the senate

    McConnell would still be the majority leader

    As much as I would have preferred Bernie, this was the only way

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    The Young Blizzard

    How could a progressive be a Republican?

    voting blue wont push progressive policies inherently

  • Mar 24, 2021

    But really it has to be class over identity, no flowery new age academic jargon, just straight up telling them how this would impact them materially and not symbolically

    Tying it to the Democratic Party would be difficult bc most of those people are consumed by partisan politics and have been taught to hate dems mostly for culture war issues, and bc most dems are not even in favor of these new deal style universal programs

    They either have to be shown that there is a new breed of Democrat that are anti establishment, not corporatist, and not the SJW “woke” caricature they’ve heard so much about, or there needs to be some hope for a 3rd party that will push these policies

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    If you actually talk to the average person in the rural South and in the Midwest, most of them don't actually like Trump for the most part. They call him a "liberal New Yorker" at the end of the day, they just clearly like him more than a Democrat.

    In theory, the best way to gain these votes would be the formation of a populist, new-blooded, genuine working-class party with people from those parts that agree with these policies, and lead a grassroots movement to eventually, over generations, move these ideas away from the "socialist boogeyman" and into a more digestible package.

    Eventually resulting with a reformed educational system that strips away right-wing propaganda and lies that plague rural areas to create a more holistic and knowledgeable population to keep on "progressive" ideals.

    In reality, this will never happen because the ideological state apparatus will only accept rich politicians with big pockets to have significant positions in office. There has never been and never will be a true working class party or even politician in power because it is straight up not possible in our electoral system.

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    The Young Blizzard

    If Bernie became president we would have a 49-50 congress and the governor of Vermont is a Republican who would have appointed a Republican so the gop would have 1 more vote in the senate

    McConnell would still be the majority leader

    As much as I would have preferred Bernie, this was the only way

    sevendaysvt.com/OffMessage/archives/2020/10/23/scott-says-he-would-replace-sanders-with-democrat-affiliated-independent

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    NBA GameBoy

    But what if the “blue” candidates are basically moderate Republicans on all the issues
    Then what’s the point

    bernie warren etc even andrew yang.
    slow change vote for someoen more progressive in primaries. instead of not voting work to change dem party to be more left

  • Mar 24, 2021
    The Young Blizzard

    If Bernie became president we would have a 49-50 congress and the governor of Vermont is a Republican who would have appointed a Republican so the gop would have 1 more vote in the senate

    McConnell would still be the majority leader

    As much as I would have preferred Bernie, this was the only way

    what about another dem thats progressive? people who are progressive just beed to back one person and push them its better than not voting

  • Mar 24, 2021
    The Young Blizzard

    Jeremy corbyn tried to do that in the Uk but he lost badly

    bc of neolibs who call everything class reductionism

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    3 replies
    CLB Fractions

    bernie warren etc even andrew yang.
    slow change vote for someoen more progressive in primaries. instead of not voting work to change dem party to be more left

    Bernie is the only one out of those 3 that really represents anything actually left of center
    I’ll give you Yang but that’s really only bc of UBI
    If there’s a genuinely good democrat that’s already arrived at the policies I believe in, sure I’ll vote for them, but that’s in spite of them being a democrat not because of it
    Trying to “push them left” is just a joke

  • Mar 24, 2021
    NBA GameBoy

    Bernie is the only one out of those 3 that really represents anything actually left of center
    I’ll give you Yang but that’s really only bc of UBI
    If there’s a genuinely good democrat that’s already arrived at the policies I believe in, sure I’ll vote for them, but that’s in spite of them being a democrat not because of it
    Trying to “push them left” is just a joke

    yang a republica

  • Mar 24, 2021
    Synopsis

    voting blue wont push progressive policies inherently

    so if AOC ran for president as democrat voting for her wouldnt do anything?

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    NBA GameBoy

    Bernie is the only one out of those 3 that really represents anything actually left of center
    I’ll give you Yang but that’s really only bc of UBI
    If there’s a genuinely good democrat that’s already arrived at the policies I believe in, sure I’ll vote for them, but that’s in spite of them being a democrat not because of it
    Trying to “push them left” is just a joke

    ubi isn't left of center its a centrist sleight of hand

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    fiveprestos

    ubi isn't left of center its a centrist sleight of hand

    If it comes with cutting social programs, then yes
    But if implemented properly and without taking funding from social security etc, or without any means testing, that’s the kind of UBI the left should be supporting

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    NBA GameBoy

    Bernie is the only one out of those 3 that really represents anything actually left of center
    I’ll give you Yang but that’s really only bc of UBI
    If there’s a genuinely good democrat that’s already arrived at the policies I believe in, sure I’ll vote for them, but that’s in spite of them being a democrat not because of it
    Trying to “push them left” is just a joke

    how is warren not center left?

  • Mar 24, 2021
    NBA GameBoy

    If it comes with cutting social programs, then yes
    But if implemented properly and without taking funding from social security etc, or without any means testing, that’s the kind of UBI the left should be supporting

    i think yang wanted it on top of social programs. but i dont remember.

    either way its center left.

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    CLB Fractions

    how is warren not center left?

    She backed down from all of her proposals that were even moderately left, is in favor of US militarism & imperialism largely due to the military industrial complex having a hold of her home state
    See anything she’s said on Russia Iran Venezuela North Korea etc

  • Synopsis

    voting blue wont push progressive policies inherently

    Like I said, the reality is republicans are far right and unless we change the two party system that won’t happen

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    NBA GameBoy

    She backed down from all of her proposals that were even moderately left, is in favor of US militarism & imperialism largely due to the military industrial complex having a hold of her home state
    See anything she’s said on Russia Iran Venezuela North Korea etc

    oh so you sayin she changed from her platform?

    but still the only way to push progressive policies is to run them in dem primary. other wise nothing will change

  • Frog

    https://www.sevendaysvt.com/OffMessage/archives/2020/10/23/scott-says-he-would-replace-sanders-with-democrat-affiliated-independent

    I stand corrected

    I have understood the governor was very moderate and socially liberal, so I guess this ain’t too surprising with context

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    fiveprestos

    ubi isn't left of center its a centrist sleight of hand

    Red states think anything left of fascism is socialism

  • Mar 24, 2021

    I think the crucial thing to know about the rural voter is that at some level they understand that both parties are corrupt and ripping them off, they’ve just been fed more effective propaganda from the right wing, largely on cultural issues that really don’t affect their material circumstances but they buy into and will defend anyway

  • What would work is democrats in red states should vote in republican primaries to not have the Qanon members win

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    The Young Blizzard

    Red states think anything left of fascism is socialism

    you think anything right of socialism is fascism. you arnt acting any better.

  • Mar 24, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    don't

    push for more reforms to make voting easier and abolish electoral college. then implement those progressive policies without their input.

    once those policies are put in place, they will see how good and helpful they are and they'll accept it. might even push for more progressive laws.