Reply
  • Mmm Hmm 😈
    OP
    Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    3 replies
    hyphy03

    MBDTF

    Reason I put MBDTF next to illmatic is because it's the next definitive rap Album.

    Illmatic had the 90's

    2000's had no definitive album

    2010's was MBDTF

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    young dyck cheney

    In 2022 Whole Lotta Red or Ūp 2 Me is closer than any of these


    End of Transmission

    They aren’t even popular enough to be in the convo before those albums, that’s even without considering other factors

  • Jul 20, 2022
    fakerickhoodie

    pop = thriller
    rap = playboi carti
    rnb = partynextdoor 1 + 2
    soul = </3²
    rock = whole lotta red
    metal = music

    Immaculate list but I don't know what this 'Thriller' album is. Maybe try replacing whatever that is with Olivia Rodrigo's Sour (2021)

  • JeffersonSteelflex

    This is pure “I just started listening to music in 2013” energy

    no it’s the sounds of right now

    that’s what I’m saying these lists would constantly evolve with the genres they’re supposed 2 represent


    End of Transmission

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    internet buddy

    Nah, Ready to Die >

    that may not even be the quintessential east coast hip hop album (illmatic or reasonable doubt)

    you’re proving my point that one album can’t define the genre

  • Jul 20, 2022
    JeffersonSteelflex

    This is pure “I just started listening to music in 2013” energy

    cantinflas avi stfu

  • Mmm Hmm 😈
    OP
    Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    young dyck cheney

    how does that refute my point


    End of Transmission

    if the sound from back then is still influencing today's sounds
    Heavily.

    Then it should still stay in the Convo

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Mmm Hmm

    Reason I put MBDTF next to illmatic is because it's the next definitive rap Album.

    Illmatic had the 90's

    2000's had no definitive album

    2010's was MBDTF

    2000s had GRODT stop the cap.

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    BRAVE

    They aren’t even popular enough to be in the convo before those albums, that’s even without considering other factors

    Jus bc some s*** was poppin in 2008 doesn’t make it representive of a genre


    End of Transmission

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Mmm Hmm

    if the sound from back then is still influencing today's sounds
    Heavily.

    Then it should still stay in the Convo

    What the f*** is illmatic influencing right now?

    the genre has evolved, music has evolved s*** doesn’t sound the way it did unless they’re doing revivalism


    End of Transmission

  • Mmm Hmm

    Reason I put MBDTF next to illmatic is because it's the next definitive rap Album.

    Illmatic had the 90's

    2000's had no definitive album

    2010's was MBDTF

    Blueprint and GROTD were definitely the definitive of the 2000s imo

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Fries

    Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea for Indie Folk

    DJ Rashad - Double Cup for Footwork

    Burial - Untrue for Dubstep

    Skrillex - Scary Monsters & Nice Sprites for Brostep

    Daft Punk - Homework for French House

    Burial Untrue dubstep?

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    ALONE

    Burial Untrue dubstep?

    it is dubstep, it's just the skrillex type s*** took the term over completely lol

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Fries

    Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea for Indie Folk

    DJ Rashad - Double Cup for Footwork

    Burial - Untrue for Dubstep

    Skrillex - Scary Monsters & Nice Sprites for Brostep

    Daft Punk - Homework for French House

    def taking that one microphones album over nmh for indie folk

  • Jul 20, 2022

    Funeral for Indie Rock

  • rvi
    Jul 20, 2022
    JeffersonSteelflex

    Because it is? lol Innervisions is Soul music and What’s Going On is literally Rhythm & Blues. Go look it up

    are you saying What's Going On is not a soul album?

    the general consensus is definitely not that one is a soul album and the other isn't, and obviously soul falls under the huge "rhythm and blues" umbrella which can be used a few different ways anyway. but that type of 70s music I typically don't see it described as "rhythm and blues" where for something like James Brown's pre-funk period I see both terms used commonly

    where do you want me to look it up?

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    lvk

    None of those albums are similar to Thriller

    Thriller is a concise album and almost every song is a hit

    I get that but at the end of the day when you take away the relativity to the album’s 9 tracks, Thriller literally has 7 huge classic smashes. Those albums I named have around the same number of classic smashes, and are the ONLY hiphop albums with that amount of classic smashes. Grad is up there too but noticeably below the others in that regard

  • Jul 20, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    young dyck cheney

    Jus bc some s*** was poppin in 2008 doesn’t make it representive of a genre


    End of Transmission

    You can’t minimize the enduring impact and love of the albums I named by saying the year they were the most popular

  • Jul 20, 2022
    young dyck cheney

    this mentality is the bane of decent music discussion


    End of Transmission

  • Jul 20, 2022
    Notmyfirst

    it is dubstep, it's just the skrillex type s*** took the term over completely lol

    Hm, I wouldn’t call it “the” dubstep album myself. It borrows a lot from ambient uk bass/garage 2step. I get what you’re saying about skrillex f***ing the term up. Anyway, it doesn’t really matter anyway, I was just surprised more than anything. I wouldn’t even know what I would classify as “THE” dubstep album.

  • Jul 20, 2022
    THANOS

    that may not even be the quintessential east coast hip hop album (illmatic or reasonable doubt)

    you’re proving my point that one album can’t define the genre

    No one putting reasonable doubt over ready to die

    Nobody

  • Jul 20, 2022
    Childhood

    def taking that one microphones album over nmh for indie folk

    fax The Glow Pt 2>>>

  • Jul 20, 2022
    Mmm Hmm

    So for rap.

    Would we define them by era then?

    Like boom bap
    Gangsta
    Conscious
    Luxury
    Etc..

    Not era just the sub genres

    Street
    Conscious
    Gangsta
    Drill
    Trap
    Melodic
    Lyrical

    Then there is albums that are traditionally all around praises by all hip hop fans regardless of what style of rap they prefer. It’ll be hard to really give rap a “It” album tbh

  • Jul 20, 2022
    young dyck cheney

    What the f*** is illmatic influencing right now?

    the genre has evolved, music has evolved s*** doesn’t sound the way it did unless they’re doing revivalism


    End of Transmission

    In case no-one told you before- that “end of transmission” gimmick is corny asf.

  • Jul 20, 2022
    hyphy03

    MBDTF

    Over 36 Chambers
    Embarrassing