Reply
  • Feb 12
    k dog 99

    I mean yeah, he's been trying to recreate the Pablo hype every album since unsuccessfully

    Donda hype was the opposite of unsuccessful & that was post trumpye

  • Plight

    I thought this too but then again, cut out all the ty dolla sign parts and you have something that is arguably even worse than jik.

    what does this even mean you’re judging an album based on a version you’ve created in your head

  • Feb 12

    Every album has at least one or two good songs.

    Performance wise it's JiK but the hooks are ridiculously catchy.

    Ye has a few interesting intuitions but it's extremely undercooked. Even Ghost Town which to me is by far and away the best track has it's issues.

    So I'd go with Ye. Vultures basically took everything interesting about Ye and integrated Into a much better album.

    Also, KSG is super overrated. His weakest collab album.

  • Ye is the most lifeless Kanye album

    JIK sucks but you can still tell listening to it it's something he wanted to make and I appreciate that

    Ye is an album of rushed throwaways meant to distract from the red hat/slavery is a choice hole he dug himself into that got overshadowed by better albums released the week before and after it. He didn't even really bother to promote or do anything with it before he moved on to Yandhi promo

  • Feb 12
    ·
    1 reply

    OP finally got an opinion after Fantano tweet

  • Feb 12
    ·
    1 reply
    k dog 99

    Donda mid as s*** lmao

    Great Value brand TLOP

    Definitely some good songs out of the era, but just overall a mess

    Better than ye jik and ksg put together

  • KILLACAM300

    Better than ye jik and ksg put together

    Better than JIK yeah

    Not the Wyoming Era albums tho

  • Vultures

  • Feb 12

    easily ye

  • k dog 99

    Easily JIK and anyone who says different is slow

    JIK has heart I have somewhat of a nice time listening to it

  • Vultures

  • Vultures is fire y’all crazy

  • Vultures and it’s not close

  • Feb 12

    JIK

  • Unpopular, but I hated KSG and still think it's his weakest project.

  • Feb 12
    Plight

    I thought this too but then again, cut out all the ty dolla sign parts and you have something that is arguably even worse than jik.

    cut out the other dude on a collab album?

    you’re dumb af

  • Feb 12
    Plight

    I thought this too but then again, cut out all the ty dolla sign parts and you have something that is arguably even worse than jik.

    What the f*** are you smoking

  • Feb 12

    Its between JIK and Ye

  • Ye

  • Ye is a depressing listen

    it’s like a blob of conventional Kanye-type songs, like it was executive produced by a Reddit Kanye fan

    Jesus is King has some mid, but it was at least full of passionate moments. If Ye doesn’t have Ghost Town, well at least JIK has Follow God, On God, God Is, and Hands On

  • And Water is a really good song, I will never understand how someone can hate it. It sounds like waking up from a nap on the beach and realizing ur still at the beach, and then being lulled back to sleep by the sound of the ocean. Incredible production

  • vultures>donda>pablo>jik>ye

  • Feb 12

    jik

  • Feb 12
    PUM PUM KILLER

    OP finally got an opinion after Fantano tweet

    im not on twitter this my first time hearing bout the tweet i listened to the album twice n was like let me see if im the only one